Benny Blanco on Failure: Lessons from 'Fuck Failure'
Benny Blanco, a renowned music producer with over 30 number-one hits, a two-time New York Times bestselling author, and a culinary personality, recently visited Google to discuss his new book, "Fuck Failure." Blanco's career, marked by collaborations with artists like Justin Bieber, Rihanna, SZA, and Halsey, has been built on an unconventional approach: embracing messiness and imperfection on the path to breakthrough ideas.
The Art of Messing Up
Blanco's book challenges the common fear of failure, particularly prevalent in high-achieving environments like tech and music. He advocates for a radical shift in mindset, encouraging people to embrace the unpolished journey to success.
Unforgettable On-Stage Disaster
Recalling an early career moment, Blanco shared a memorable disaster from his time as a DJ for the band 3OH!3 on Warped Tour. Using a desktop computer as his setup, which was simply plugged into a headphone jack, a drunk guitarist accidentally pulled the plug, silencing all background music and guitar sounds. Blanco had to restart the computer in front of 20,000 people, an experience he found "sucked."
Dropping the Mental Baggage of Perfection
Blanco challenges the societal pressure to follow a rigid path of success (school, college, good job). He believes this fear stems from what our parents, and their parents, were taught. He encourages people to shed the embarrassment of starting small or failing publicly. He emphasizes that most of his creative endeavors—95% of the songs he makes, and most ideas for books or TV shows—never see the light of day. However, it only takes one good idea to move forward.
He illustrates this with an analogy: if someone wants to be a Lakers player, it's probably not going to happen, but pursuing that dream might lead them to a related field like sports management, announcing, or even being a "leg stretcher" for the team. The key is to start and pursue what you love, even if the initial goal isn't met.
From Pop Hooks to Full-Length Books
Transitioning from crafting three-minute pop hooks to writing full-length books was a daunting but necessary step for Blanco. He views all creative endeavors as similar in their initial challenge. His strategy for overcoming this is to commit publicly: he tells all his friends about an idea as if it's already happening, creating accountability. This "manifestation" pushes him forward, even if he doesn't fully believe in himself in the moment. He also notes that if an endeavor fails, those who mock it are not true friends.
Unlearning the Fear of Public Failure
Blanco asserts that "nobody's keeping a scorecard on your life except you." He unlearned the fear of public failure by simply doing what he wanted to do: create. He refuses to let others' opinions dictate his creative output. When he makes a song, he immediately shares it with friends, just as he did as a teenager, seeking shared experience rather than just validation.
He shared a powerful anecdote about a doctor who, after reading his book, quit her 30-year career to open a bakery, stating she "just needed to switch my shit up" and didn't care if it failed. This highlights the transformative power of embracing change and taking risks. Blanco also points out that it's never too late to start, citing examples like Bill Withers, who didn't start singing until his 40s, and Mel Robbins, who found massive success in her 50s after years of struggle. He emphasizes the immense power of the human mind to achieve almost anything.
Shutting Up and Relaxing in the Face of Failure
When in the midst of a high-stakes failure, Blanco advises a period of "shutting up and relaxing." He redefines success beyond monetary gain or traditional achievements, including things like getting a child to eat vegetables, complimenting a partner, or reconnecting with family.
His tactical approach to failure is to allow for a grace period: "Today we're allowed to mope." This means taking a day to be upset, eat ice cream, and cry. But the next day, it's about getting up, taking a shower, and trying again, perhaps with new knowledge or a different approach. He refuses to dwell on past failures, choosing instead to "roll the dice again."
Creating a Safe Space for "Terrible Ideas"
As a producer, Blanco's superpower is drawing the best out of people. He acknowledges that 95% of what he creates is "garbage," but the 5% changes the world. When working with major artists, he acts as a "therapist," aiming to disarm them and make them feel comfortable and heard.
Even if an idea is "stupid," he lets people express it without immediate judgment. Shutting down an idea too quickly can prevent future contributions. He suggests that sometimes a "bad" idea can spark an amazing one later. He famously recounts a hit song that originated from sampling a YouTube video of a child farting, demonstrating that "no idea is too stupid."
Discarding Bad Advice and Pushing Forward
Blanco's worst career advice came indirectly from observing people in high places treating others poorly. He learned what not to do, vowing to create a different environment when he had his own company.
When a new feature or idea crashes and burns, Blanco advises a two-step process. First, honestly assess if the idea truly "sucked" or if it was good but poorly timed. He's had number-one songs that were rejected by every artist for years before finding the right timing and place. If the idea is good, he "tucks it back" and revisits it later. The key is to never stop generating and pitching ideas.
Maintaining Routine Amidst Silence
In creative work, the applause is visible, but the months of silence and rejection are not. To combat self-doubt when ideas receive no reaction, Blanco avoids playing music for others while he's creating. He believes even subtle head or eye movements can influence his creative process. He also emphasizes the importance of "reading the room" when presenting ideas, waiting for the right moment and mood.
His practical routine involves maintaining a structured day. Waking up and following a consistent schedule helps him stay grounded and avoid going "insane."
The Three-Legged Stool: Work, Health, and Loved Ones
Blanco experienced early success at 20, which led to a mental breakdown because he was solely focused on work, neglecting his health and loved ones. He openly discusses seeking help, emphasizing that therapy, medicine, or alternative practices like yoga are all valid ways to cope.
He realized he was driven by fear of his time running out, rather than genuine passion. This experience taught him the importance of balancing work with family, friends, and personal well-being. He recommends a "temp check" every six months and, at the end of each year, creating a list of goals that includes vacations and new hobbies, alongside business objectives. He stresses the need to "water all the plants" in life.
Relying on Others and Embracing Boredom
When asked about deciding whether to do something himself or rely on others, Blanco humbly states, "Everyone is better than me." He believes in delegating and checking his ego at the door. Learning to delegate was challenging, but essential. He acknowledges that sometimes delegation leads to worse results, but it's a learning process. Being a leader, he explains, sometimes means simply bringing the right people together and knowing when to step in.
Regarding success, Blanco admits he struggled to "bask in the glory" of his early number-one hits and awards, always focusing on what was next. He now advises younger artists to appreciate their achievements. While success can feel like relief rather than pure happiness, he combats boredom by constantly trying new things and exploring different genres, even if it means making things "harder on myself in a good way." He compares it to a parent who, despite knowing their child loves a PB&J, tries making something new, ready to revert if it doesn't work.
Takeaways
- Blanco argues that embracing messiness and public failure is essential for breakthrough ideas, challenging the fear that high‑achieving environments often instill.
- He creates accountability by publicly announcing ideas, treating them as already happening, which pushes him forward even when confidence wavers.
- Blanco cultivates a safe space for "terrible" ideas, believing that 95% may be garbage but the remaining 5% can change the world, so no concept should be dismissed too quickly.
- He stresses balancing work, health, and relationships, using a structured routine, regular self‑check‑ins, and delegation to avoid burnout and maintain creative momentum.
- After a setback, he recommends a grace period to process emotions, then resetting with basic self‑care before re‑engaging with fresh perspective and renewed effort.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does Benny Blanco recommend dealing with a failed idea that might still be good?
Blanco advises first to honestly assess whether the idea truly 'sucked' or was simply mistimed; if it’s good, he files it away and revisits later, trusting that timing can turn a rejected concept into a hit.
What is the purpose of publicly announcing an idea according to Blanco?
Blanco says publicly sharing an idea creates immediate accountability, turning a vague thought into a commitment that forces him to act, even when confidence is low, because friends and peers expect progress and keeps him motivated.
Who is Talks at Google on YouTube?
Talks at Google is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.