Women and Money Courses: Design, Naming, and Enrollment Strategies
This article summarizes a session on "Women and Money," featuring two presentations: one on a new, highly successful course at Ohio State University and another on a 25-year-old financial literacy program for women at Smith College. Both presentations highlight the importance of course structure, naming, and outreach in attracting students, particularly women, to financial education.
Ohio State University's "Women and Money: Citizenship in a Modern World" Course
Cecilia, a professor and chair of consumer sciences at Ohio State, developed and co-teaches a new four-credit hour course titled "Women and Money: Citizenship in a Modern World." The course is open to all undergraduate students and is part of the university's general education (Gen Ed) curriculum.
Course Success and Enrollment
The course launched in Spring 2023 with 1,000 students and saw an enrollment of 1,500 students in Fall 2023. The university had to cap enrollment at 1,500 due to demand from other courses, indicating potential for even higher numbers.
Key Factors for Success
Cecilia attributes the course's success to several deliberate design choices:
- Gen Ed Placement: It's placed within a required Gen Ed theme (citizenship) that every Ohio State student must take.
- Four Credit Hours: This is a significant draw as it replaces two three-credit hour courses, making it efficient for students to fulfill requirements.
- Simple and Consistent Structure: The course maintains a uniform weekly structure for lectures and assignments, making it accessible to students from diverse academic backgrounds (e.g., nursing, biology, finance).
- Clean Design and Interactive Videos: The course is easy to navigate, featuring four interactive video lessons each week. They use ThingLink software to embed questions and interactive elements into lecture videos, enhancing engagement.
- Relevant Topic: Personal finance is inherently interesting to students.
- Catchy Title: "Women and Money" is memorable and effective, appearing prominently in course catalogs and attracting attention.
Course Team and Student Demographics
The course is taught by three instructors and supported by 31 teaching assistants. Bendy McBroom is the lead instructor, focusing on financial citizenship and personal finance. Debbie Sharp, an expert in online education, teaches the introductory citizenship lecture. Cecilia teaches the research lecture and handles administration.
Student demographics for Fall 2023 show: * Gender: 63% female, 37% male. This is a significant achievement, especially compared to the CFP program, which typically has only 20% women. The course aims to increase the pipeline of women into financial advising. * Gen Ed Students: Approximately a quarter of students are taking it for Gen Ed credit. * Origin: Most students are from Ohio, typical for Ohio State. * Grade Level: A large number of seniors, as students often postpone Gen Ed courses. Efforts are underway to stagger enrollment to attract more freshmen and sophomores. * Majors: While finance is a natural draw, a surprising number of students come from biology, mechanical engineering, chemical engineering, and marketing, often seeking to fulfill the four-credit hour required theme.
Course Content and Assignments
The Canvas page features a structured, clean layout with modules for citizenship, financial citizenship, personal finance, and a field survey. Weekly assignments include: * Quizzes * Discussion Posts * Life Skills Assignments: Practical tasks like starting to invest with $5 or downloading a credit report. * Field Survey Assignments: This research track earns the fourth credit hour. Students develop research questions, write proposals, create online surveys using Google Forms, and collect data from five other Ohio State students. The data is then analyzed using AI, and students create infographics and explain their projects to friends or family, fulfilling a public impact component required by the Gen Ed curriculum.
Recommendations for Course Development
Cecilia offers six unique features and recommendations:
- Recorded Guest Lectures: Two to three recorded guest lectures weekly from financial planners, professionals, politicians, and authors make the content real and show its application.
- Funding: A $100,000 gift from Peggy Rulin, a financial planning firm owner, was crucial for course development, allowing for hiring expertise.
- Don't Start from Scratch: Adapt successful course structures from other popular courses at your institution, even if they are in different subjects. Ohio State's course copied the structure of a successful nutrition and exercise course.
- No Textbook: Instead, use short excerpts from diverse sources:
- Citizenship: Literature (e.g., Amanda Gorman, Jane Austen, Isabel Wilkerson).
- Financial Citizenship: Economics papers (e.g., Anna Lusardi, Lauren Willis, Claudia Goldin) and books like Kayla Scandlin's "In This Economy."
- Personal Finance: Bestsellers (e.g., Beth Kobliner, Vivian Tu, Ramit Sethi) with relevant subchapters.
- Field Survey: Survey research papers.
- Dedicated Website: Create a website with videos and FAQs to inform students about the new course, especially for a four-credit commitment. This helps address common questions, such as whether male students can benefit (yes, it's general personal finance with an application to women's participation).
- Willingness to Innovate and Teamwork: Embrace software packages for seamless, attractive course delivery (like social media) and ensure digital accessibility. Work as a team; don't develop such a course alone.
Political Context and Course Naming
The course's name, "Women and Money," was a point of discussion among colleagues who worried it might not attract a large crowd. However, Cecilia and the funder strongly supported it. The full name, "Citizenship in a Modern World," also helps. Despite Ohio having laws against diversity-related topics, the course was approved. Cecilia noted that the proposal language was kept "very clean, very neutral" and focused on "women's participation," aligning with guidelines and using AI to ensure compliance.
Smith College's Women and Financial Independence (WFI) Program
Manaz discusses a financial literacy program for women at Smith College, celebrating its 25th anniversary. The program, initially called "Women and Financial Independence" (WFI), aimed to educate students, alums, and women in general to build financial knowledge and skills.
Program Philosophy and Research
The program was founded on the understanding that effective personal finance education is a lifelong process, as financial needs change across different life stages. Research conducted by surveying Smith alums (educated women with bachelor's degrees, some with PhDs or MBAs) revealed: * Gender Gap: Women generally had less financial knowledge than men. * Life Expectancy and Income Disparities: Women have longer life expectancies and persistent income disparities, requiring greater retirement savings and better investment strategies. * Interrupted Careers: Women often have interrupted careers for childcare or family care, impacting income and retirement preparedness. * Math Ability vs. Financial Knowledge: Low personal financial knowledge persisted even among women with high math knowledge, debunking the myth that lack of math ability was the cause. * Professional vs. Personal Finance: Women in financial services with leadership positions often had strong professional financial knowledge but lacked personal financial knowledge. * Age and Education: Older women and those with MBA degrees had higher financial knowledge, suggesting that life stages and advanced education drive learning. * Confidence Matters: Beyond knowledge, confidence in financial decision-making is crucial. The program aimed to develop this confidence.
Program Building and Outreach
- Naming: The name "Women and Financial Independence" was crucial to signal its target audience. The slogan "You are not truly independent until and unless you are financially independent" reinforced this message.
- Communication and Funding: Extensive media coverage (local and national) provided automatic advertisement, attracting attention and funding. Donations ranged from $50 checks from individuals to significant contributions from alums, financial institutions, and endowments. Manaz secured over $1 million from Goldman Sachs.
- Name Change Impact: In 2016, the program's name changed to the "Jiller Conway Innovation and Entrepreneurship Center," named after Smith College's first woman president. While honoring, this change reduced the program's effectiveness because "financial education" was no longer explicit in the name.
Course Offerings and Structure
Smith College, being a liberal arts institution, faced challenges in offering credit-bearing courses in personal finance due to academic requirements. Therefore, courses were offered as non-credit: * Main Courses: * "Financing Life" * "Principles of Investing" * "Interpreting Financial News" * Success: These courses were highly successful, attracting over 100 students per session, including students, faculty, and staff. One staff member attended "Financing Life" for 20 years, eventually becoming a millionaire and crediting the program. * Popular Instructors: The success was partly due to popular faculty like Randy Bartlett, who taught "Financing Life." * Lunchtime Sessions: Courses were offered during lunchtime with free lunch provided, making them accessible and attractive. * Parallel Professional Lectures: Each course was complemented by local professionals giving lectures on related topics (e.g., a real estate agent discussing home buying). * Early and Late Career Workshops: * "Dollars and Cents and Budgeting in College": A 1-2 hour workshop for first-year students. * "From Backpack to Briefcase": A 3-hour boot camp for graduating students on managing money in the real world. These attracted around 300 students, significant for a small college.
Challenges and Evolution
- Faculty Retirement: The retirement of popular faculty (Randy Bartlett and Roger Kaufman) created a void, as finding replacements for non-credit courses was difficult.
- Increased Competition for Lunchtime: Other college activities began offering lunchtime programs with food, increasing the opportunity cost for students to attend WFI sessions.
- New Approach: A mathematics colleague now teaches "Demystifying Money" and "Foundations and Investing," incorporating behavioral finance. Attendance is smaller (30-50 students) and primarily students, with fewer faculty and staff.
- Peer-to-Peer Education: The program has shifted focus to "Money Mentors"—students trained in financial knowledge who provide peer-to-peer advice. This approach makes students more comfortable asking questions and builds confidence in the mentors.
Discussion Highlights
The Power of Naming
Both presenters emphasized the critical role of course naming. Cecilia's "Women and Money" title, despite initial concerns, proved inclusive, attracting 37% male students while significantly boosting female enrollment. The course's strong placement within the Gen Ed curriculum and its focus on general personal finance with an application to women's participation made it appealing to all. Manaz's "Women and Financial Independence" program also leveraged its name to clearly communicate its mission and attract its target audience.
Attracting Diverse Students
Cecilia noted that the "Women and Money" course attracts students from various majors, including engineering and biology, who are looking to fulfill Gen Ed requirements efficiently. The course's broad appeal demonstrates that a well-structured and relevant personal finance course can transcend disciplinary boundaries.
Overcoming Political Hurdles
Cecilia shared how Ohio State's "Women and Money" course navigated state laws against diversity-related topics. By carefully crafting the course proposal with neutral language focusing on "women's participation" and using AI to ensure compliance, the course was approved.
Increasing Women in Financial Planning
Both presenters acknowledged the industry's need for more female financial advisors. Cecilia hopes her course will serve as an entry point, introducing more women to personal finance and potentially leading them to pursue financial planning as a major or career. The challenge remains in translating this initial interest into professional pathways.
Course Promotion and Enrollment Growth
Cecilia's team actively promoted the "Women and Money" course through a dedicated website with videos and FAQs, outreach to academic advisors and student organizations, and even engaging with student discussions on Reddit. This proactive marketing, combined with the course's inherent value, led to rapid enrollment growth.
Sustainability of Programs
Manaz highlighted the challenge of sustaining programs when relying on specific faculty or when external factors (like increased competition for lunchtime slots) change. The shift to peer-to-peer education at Smith College is an adaptation to these challenges, ensuring continued financial literacy support for students.
Takeaways
- Ohio State's "Women and Money" course achieved rapid enrollment growth, reaching 1,500 students in its first fall by placing the four‑credit class in a required Gen Ed citizenship theme and offering a concise, credit‑efficient structure.
- Key design elements such as a catchy title, consistent weekly layout, interactive video lessons, and a field‑survey research component contributed to high student engagement and attracted majors beyond finance, including engineering and biology.
- The program’s success was supported by a $100,000 gift, a dedicated website with FAQs, recorded guest lectures, and a team of three instructors plus 31 TAs, demonstrating the importance of funding and collaborative delivery.
- Smith College’s 25‑year Women and Financial Independence program showed that clear naming, non‑credit lunchtime courses, and peer‑to‑peer “Money Mentor” models can sustain financial literacy outreach despite faculty turnover and competition for space.
- Both initiatives illustrate that neutral, purpose‑driven naming, alignment with curriculum requirements, and strategic outreach are critical for attracting diverse students and advancing women’s participation in financial careers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Ohio State place the "Women and Money" course in a required Gen Ed citizenship theme?
Placing the course in a mandatory Gen Ed citizenship requirement guarantees that every undergraduate must satisfy the credit, driving enrollment regardless of major. The alignment also frames personal finance as a civic skill, making it relevant to a wide student audience and supporting the course’s rapid growth.
How did renaming Smith College’s program to the Jiller Conway Innovation and Entrepreneurship Center affect its impact?
The 2016 rename removed the explicit reference to financial education, making the program less identifiable to prospective participants seeking money‑management training. Attendance and visibility declined, prompting a shift toward smaller peer‑mentor workshops to maintain relevance despite the less descriptive title.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.