Early Wealth Building: 529 Plans, Enrollment, and Literacy

•

 57 min video

•

 8 min read

YouTube video ID: UPX_eLSegH8

Source: YouTube video by Stanford Graduate School of Business — Watch original video

PDF

This session focused on wealth building in early life, exploring financial tools like 529 plans and "Trump accounts," alongside the knowledge and support systems that enable families to utilize these opportunities. The discussion featured three distinguished speakers: Guillermo Berti from Vanguard, Michael Deadman from the National Endowment for Financial Education (NEFE), and Libby Schaaf, President and CEO of the Bay Area Council and former Mayor of Oakland. Olivia Mitchell, a professor at the Wharton School, moderated the session.

The Landscape of 529 Plans: Insights from Illinois

Guillermo Berti presented findings from six years of research on 529 college savings plans, also known as college savings accounts. These state-administered, tax-advantaged plans allow parents to save money for education-related expenses, with the funds growing tax-free and withdrawals also tax-free when used for qualified educational costs. These plans have existed for over 20-30 years in some states, with virtually every US state offering them. Currently, over $600 billion is invested in these plans annually. Berti emphasized that 529 plans serve as a complementary tool to financial aid or student loans, with every dollar invested potentially reducing future student loan debt.

Despite their widespread adoption and discussion, there has been limited systematic analysis of 529 plans. Berti's research, initiated in 2020 with the Illinois State Treasurer's Office, analyzed almost 1 million accounts over 23 years, yielding novel insights:

  • Concentration of Take-up: Adoption of 529 plans is concentrated in higher-income areas, correlating with household income and higher education attainment at the zip code level.
  • Increased Adoption: Despite the concentration, adoption has increased across every zip code in Illinois, with an estimated 25% of children born in Illinois between 2003 and 2023 having an account.
  • Effectiveness of Financial Incentives: A randomized controlled trial (RCT) with 150,000 families in Illinois tested the impact of financial incentives ($0, $10, $50, or $100) for opening an account. Surprisingly, only 11 out of 37,500 individuals in the $100 incentive group opened an account. This suggests that light-touch financial incentives alone are not sufficient to drive take-up, even when people engage with the information.
  • Role of Financial Literacy: A survey of Illinois parents revealed that those with 529 accounts tend to be more financially literate, even after controlling for income and assets. Low financial literacy leads to incorrect beliefs about the future cost of college, the impact of contributions, and the benefits of compound interest.
  • Impact on Educational Outcomes: Linking 529 plan records to the National Student Clearinghouse data for over 200,000 children showed a correlation between higher account balances and a greater likelihood of attending more selective colleges. For those attending two-year community colleges, a slightly higher balance correlated with a better likelihood of transferring to a four-year institution. Berti acknowledged this is a correlation, not causation, and further research is needed.

This research has led to the formation of the first-of-its-kind research consortium for 529 plans, involving institutions like Stanford, the University of Chicago, NEFE, Vanguard, the National Association of State Treasurers, and five states (Illinois, Maine, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Utah). This consortium aims to conduct further experiments, surveys, and data analysis at scale.

The Power of Hope and Automatic Enrollment

Libby Schaaf, drawing on her experience as Mayor of Oakland, emphasized the transformative power of early wealth building, particularly for low-income families. She cited the Willie Elliott study, which found that low-income children with even less than $500 in a college savings account are three times more likely to go to college and four times more likely to finish.

Schaaf shared three stories to illustrate her points:

  1. "I don't want your financial literacy until I have some finances": A low-income parent expressed anger at the suggestion of financial literacy education when she lacked financial assets. This highlighted that financial literacy is most effective when there's a tangible asset to inspire hope.
  2. Carelli's Story and the Oakland Promise: The Oakland Promise program, inspired by the Willie Elliott study, provided newborn babies of Medicaid-eligible parents with a $500 529 account and a financial coach. Elementary schools also received funding to foster a college-going culture and educate parents about 529s, offering seed incentives for opening accounts. Schaaf recounted a visit to an elementary school where kindergarteners proudly showed a "K to C" (Kindergarten to College) bulletin board featuring alumni who had gone to college. This demonstrated the power of a trusted messenger (the school) and creating a college-bound identity.
  3. Tiffany's Story: Beyond College Savings: Tiffany, a single mother in the Brilliant Babies program, used her financial coach to learn about saving and financial decision-making. She eventually achieved her goal of buying a home in Oakland, demonstrating how college savings accounts can be a gateway to broader financial literacy and stability.

Schaaf highlighted two key lessons from California's CalKids 529 program:

  • Automatic Enrollment is Key: In California, every baby born in a hospital automatically gets a CalKids account. Low-income first graders receive $500, foster care children receive $1,000, and unhoused children receive an additional $500. This automatic enrollment ensures that accounts are earning interest from birth, even if parents are initially unaware.
  • Trusted Messengers: The combination of government approval and trusted messengers (schools, teachers, principals, pediatricians) is highly effective in promoting these programs.

Schaaf concluded by noting the bipartisan support for early wealth building for children, citing examples like Gavin Newsom praising "Trump accounts" and Ted Cruz and Cory Booker jointly advocating for the cause.

Connecting Financial Literacy to Wealth Building

Michael Deadman emphasized the importance of educational interventions in translating financial knowledge into action. NEFE is actively involved in advocating for financial education in high schools and colleges. He highlighted that increased financial literacy, as demonstrated by Berti's research, is crucial for improving savings behavior and economic mobility.

Deadman raised critical questions for educators and practitioners:

  • How are wealth-building opportunities like 529 accounts and "Trump accounts" covered in existing curricula?
  • How are these opportunities addressed in adult education interventions like financial coaching and counseling?

He stressed that financial education is not all created equal. While basic requirements for financial education are important, it's crucial to ensure that curricula effectively inform individuals about wealth-building opportunities. NEFE aims to expand the understanding of wealth building beyond college savings to encompass various opportunities and vehicles, clarifying the relationship between improved literacy and economic mobility.

Discussion and Audience Questions

An audience member, Michael Manahan, questioned whether tax shelters like 529 plans are effective in changing the culture of people who don't inherently prioritize saving. He argued that behavioral change, rather than tax breaks, is the primary driver of wealth accumulation.

Berti responded by explaining that 529 plans can act as a "commitment device" and a form of "mental accounting," helping parents earmark funds for a specific goal. He reiterated that financial incentives alone are often insufficient, as demonstrated by their RCT. Instead, he emphasized that many parents massively underestimate future college costs, overestimate financial aid, and underestimate the power of compound interest. Education on these basic concepts can be more impactful than incentives.

Deadman added that while behavioral change is important, it's also about overcoming misinformed beliefs and feelings of hopelessness. He argued that education, delivered by trusted individuals and integrated into appropriate interventions, can help people overcome resistance to saving and make good financial choices.

Schaaf reinforced the idea that automatic enrollment bypasses the need for parents to actively enroll, which can be a barrier for those who don't prioritize it or don't qualify for tax benefits. She also highlighted that income from investing is growing faster than income from wages, making it crucial to give low-income families access to investment growth.

Natalia from the World Economic Forum questioned the financial ROI of college and homeownership, given rising costs and the potential for higher returns on capital than labor. She asked if these investments are always the best financially.

Berti acknowledged the uncertainty about future ROI but pointed out the flexibility of 529 plans, which can be used for various forms of higher education (trade schools, apprenticeships) and even rolled over into Roth IRAs if college is not pursued. He mentioned ongoing research to understand how parents navigate this uncertainty, particularly in light of AI's potential impact on the labor market and the value of college degrees.

An Illinois State Treasurer's Office representative added that 529 funds can be used for any form of higher education beyond high school, including trade schools and apprenticeships, making them more broadly applicable than just traditional college.

Deadman emphasized the intrinsic value of education, arguing that financial education can produce better citizens with more confidence and capacity to advocate for the world they want to live in. He stressed that asset building and continuous education can help alleviate anxiety about the financial payoff of investing in education.

Nick Suganas from the Smith School at the University of Maryland asked Olivia Mitchell for her favorite method of childhood financial development. Mitchell shared her "Bank of Mom" system, an Excel spreadsheet where her daughters could track their money, earn more by doing chores, and learn the value of money and budgeting.

Suganas then asked about integrating personal accounting and accountability into financial education, suggesting that understanding assets, liabilities, and equity is foundational. Deadman responded that NEFE is agnostic about the specific integration methods, as long as the content is relevant, timely, and delivered by qualified individuals. He highlighted NEFE's "personal finance ecosystem" schematic, which visualizes how financial education interacts with other critical components of financial well-being, including home life and early financial discussions.

James Gertie from the Wharton Global Youth Program, a former high school teacher, asked Libby Schaaf for examples of programs that effectively engage individuals who feel they lack the finances to benefit from financial literacy. Schaaf reiterated the importance of automatic enrollment, citing the CalKids program where many children have accounts without their families' immediate knowledge. She encouraged attendees to research "promise" programs in their local areas, emphasizing that providing a starting asset makes financial literacy more meaningful.

  Takeaways

  • Guillermo Berti’s six‑year study of Illinois 529 accounts shows that adoption is higher in affluent zip codes but has risen to about 25 % of children born between 2003‑2023 across the state.
  • A randomized trial offering up to $100 incentives to open a 529 account produced only 11 new accounts, indicating that modest cash incentives alone do not drive enrollment.
  • Parents with 529 accounts tend to be more financially literate, and higher account balances correlate with attendance at more selective colleges and higher transfer rates from community colleges.
  • Automatic enrollment programs like California’s CalKids, which deposit $500‑$1,000 into newborns’ accounts, create early assets that boost hope and make financial‑literacy messages more effective.
  • Experts stress that trusted messengers—schools, teachers, pediatricians—and integrated financial‑education curricula are essential for translating knowledge about wealth‑building tools into actual saving behavior.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the $100 incentive group in the Illinois 529 RCT produce so few new accounts?

The trial showed that even a $100 incentive led only 11 out of 37,500 participants to open an account because light‑touch financial incentives are insufficient without deeper financial literacy or motivation; many families remain unaware of the benefits or lack the immediate need to act, limiting the incentive’s impact.

How does automatic enrollment in California’s CalKids program improve financial‑literacy outcomes for low‑income children?

Automatic enrollment places a $500‑$1,000 seed account in every newborn’s name, ensuring assets begin accruing interest from birth; this tangible asset creates hope, makes financial‑literacy lessons relevant, and removes the enrollment barrier, leading to higher awareness and participation among families who might otherwise ignore savings programs.

Who is Stanford Graduate School of Business on YouTube?

Stanford Graduate School of Business is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.

Does this page include the full transcript of the video?

Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.

Helpful resources related to this video

If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.

Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.

Full transcript is not shown on this page

This page focuses on the summary and original notes. For full verification, refer to the original YouTube video.

PDF