Kakistocracy Explained: Why the Worst Rule and Corrupt Systems Thrive
Kakistocracy, a term derived from the Greek words "kakistos" (worst) and "kratos" (rule), signifies "rule by the worst." This concept, explored by thinkers like James Russell Lowell and William Frederic Faber, suggests that many modern governments tend to degenerate into systems where the most corrupt and self-serving individuals rise to power.
The Nature of a Kakistocracy
In a kakistocracy, government positions are filled by individuals who are corrupt, dishonest, power-hungry, manipulative, and sometimes sociopathic. Instead of serving the public, these individuals, known as kakistocrats, exploit their political power to:
- Advance their personal interests.
- Enrich themselves and their associates.
- Satisfy their desires for wealth, power, and control.
This leads to a ruling elite that prospers while the general populace becomes impoverished and society declines.
The Inherent Tendency Towards Kakistocracy
Modern states inherently tend towards kakistocracy because they divide society into rulers and ruled, granting the former powers, privileges, and resources unavailable to ordinary citizens. This attracts not only those genuinely motivated by public service but also those seeking wealth, power, and control over others. Individuals driven by the latter motives often possess qualities like cunning, manipulation, and ruthlessness, which give them an advantage in the political arena, leading to their disproportionate representation in the ruling class.
Friedrich Hayek, in "The Road to Serfdom," observed this phenomenon in his chapter "Why the Worst Get on Top," noting that "the readiness to do bad things becomes a path to promotion and power," and "the unscrupulous and uninhibited are likely to be more successful." Even democratic governments, despite constitutional limits on power, can devolve into systems where voting merely replaces one set of political predators with another, as William Kovacs states in "Reform the Kakistocracy": "Our founders formed a representative republic. We have formed a kakistocracy."
How Kakistocrats Consolidate Power
As political predators gain power, they actively reshape governmental institutions to facilitate their illicit activities. They enact laws, regulations, and reforms that protect their privileges and appoint unscrupulous individuals to key positions within law enforcement, the military, and the judiciary. This increasing corruption discourages principled individuals from entering public service, turning the struggle for political power into a contest among the most ruthless and unethical. Charles Forbes René de Montalembert noted in 1855 that "no unmixed form of government has ever long continued to rule for the good of the governed. In a generation or two the orderly democracy becomes a kakistocracy, or government of the worst."
Jobbery and Collabortakers
Kakistocrats engage in "jobbery," which is the exploitation of public office for private gain. Despite modest official salaries, they accumulate extraordinary wealth through immoral, corrupt, and criminal dealings. William Kovacs highlights that instances of jobbery are commonplace, often going unprosecuted or even approved by ethics panels established by the kakistocrats themselves.
To facilitate jobbery, kakistocrats form alliances with powerful and wealthy individuals and institutions in the private sector, whom Kovacs terms "collabortakers." These collabortakers "collaborate with the kakistocrats to create a legal system that allows them to take as much of the wealth of the nation as they can take without inciting a revolt."
The Role of Lobbying
Lobbying is a primary tool for collabortakers. Large corporations, pharmaceutical companies, defense contractors, tech companies, and special-interest groups spend billions annually to gain access to kakistocrats who write laws, direct public spending, and determine policy. Through campaign contributions, political favors, gifts, and promises of lucrative post-office employment, lobbyists leverage state power to benefit the wealthy interests they represent. Kovacs emphasizes that lobbyists are hired to get results for their masters, not to serve the nation's best interests.
Lobbyists influence critical government decisions, from military budgets and foreign policy to drug pricing and regulatory standards. Corporations use lobbying to create regulatory barriers, restrict competition, and secure favorable treatment, finding it an easier path to wealth accumulation than market competition.
The Influence of Banks and Financial Institutions
Banks and financial institutions are among the most active collabortakers. J.R.R. Tolkien recognized this close relationship, suggesting that some bankers wield such political influence that politicians become their puppets, stating, "The main mark of modern governments is that we do not know who governs…We see the politician and not his backer; still less the backer of the backer; or, what is most important of all, the banker of the backer."
The Central Bank as a Tool of Kakistocracy
A powerful tool of kakistocracy is the central bank, which can expand the money supply to finance government spending and debt beyond what taxation and borrowing alone could sustain. This monetary power allows the ruling class to access vast sums without directly raising taxes.
This newly created money is used for various purposes:
- Bloated government programs: Presented as serving the public good.
- Foreign wars: Benefiting political and corporate interests at the cost of lives and economic damage.
- Jobbery: Funneled into contracts, subsidies, and programs that enrich kakistocrats and reward collabortakers.
While kakistocrats and collabortakers benefit from this access to new money, the citizenry bears the ultimate cost. An increase in the money supply leads to inflation, reducing the purchasing power of wages and savings. Kakistocrats and collabortakers, who receive the new money first, benefit before prices rise. Economist Murray Rothbard described this monetary expansion as a "hidden 'tax'" that "expropriates (i.e., gain at the expense of) the late receivers," amounting to "stealthy and insidious robbery."
Corruption of the Judiciary
In a kakistocracy, the judiciary, intended as an independent check on political power, becomes absorbed into the corrupt system. Kovacs notes that judicial appointments are often based on political belief, affiliation, and support from kakistocrats, rather than merit. Under this corrupted legal structure, laws protect kakistocrats from the people.
With the judiciary no longer an effective check, kakistocrats are free to enact laws and policies that protect their privileges and advance their selfish interests, perpetuating a corrupt ruling class. Ayn Rand, in "Atlas Shrugged," warned of a society doomed when:
- Production requires permission from non-producers.
- Money flows to those dealing in favors, not goods.
- Men get richer through graft and pull rather than work, and laws protect them against the people.
- Corruption is rewarded, and honesty becomes self-sacrifice.
Takeaways
- Kakistocracy, from the Greek words for “worst” and “rule,” describes a system where the most corrupt and self‑serving individuals dominate government.
- Modern states gravitate toward kakistocracy because the division of rulers and ruled offers power, privileges, and resources that lure ambitious, manipulative actors who outcompete principled citizens for office.
- Kakistocrats consolidate power by reshaping institutions, appointing loyalists to the judiciary, military and law‑enforcement, and exploiting the central bank’s money‑creation ability to fund bloated programs and personal enrichment.
- Through “jobbery,” kakistocrats partner with wealthy “collabortakers” and lobbyists who buy influence, ensuring legislation and contracts funnel public wealth to the ruling elite while avoiding accountability.
- The resulting monetary expansion acts as a hidden tax that inflates prices, eroding citizens’ purchasing power while the elite profit, and a corrupted judiciary removes legal checks, cementing the rule of the worst.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Hayek say the unscrupulous are more likely to be successful in politics?
Hayek argues that the readiness to do bad things creates a path to promotion and power, because political systems reward results over integrity, allowing ruthless individuals to outmaneuver honest competitors and secure positions of authority despite ethical costs.
What is "jobbery" as described in the article?
Jobbery is the exploitation of public office for private gain, where officials use their official positions to amass wealth through corrupt deals, contracts, and subsidies, often with little or no prosecution and the legal system frequently turns a blind eye, reinforcing the kakistocratic cycle.
Who is Academy of Ideas on YouTube?
Academy of Ideas is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
How Kakistocrats Consolidate Power
As political predators gain power, they actively reshape governmental institutions to facilitate their illicit activities. They enact laws, regulations, and reforms that protect their privileges and appoint unscrupulous individuals to key positions within law enforcement, the military, and the judiciary. This increasing corruption discourages principled individuals from entering public service, turning the struggle for political power into a contest among the most ruthless and unethical. Charles Forbes René de Montalembert noted in 1855 that "no unmixed form of government has ever long continued to rule for the good of the governed. In a generation or two the orderly democracy becomes a kakistocracy, or government of the worst."
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.