Girl Boss Feminism Critique: How It Devalues Feminine Choices
There's a growing concern that some forms of feminism, particularly "girl boss feminism," have become deeply misogynistic, devaluing traditionally feminine roles and choices while elevating only those achievements historically associated with men. This perspective suggests that the movement has lost its way, becoming critical of femininity itself rather than uplifting all women.
The Devaluation of Feminine Choices
A striking example of this phenomenon involves a high-powered executive who, after having her third child during the pandemic, decided to leave her demanding tech job to become a full-time mother. Despite her impressive career achievements, when she joined a new moms' group, she was met with subtle disdain. One mother expressed regret at not knowing her "when you were still working, you know, when you had a lot going on." This incident highlights a worldview where a woman's value is diminished if she chooses a path perceived as "just a mom," even if that path is a conscious and fulfilling choice after reaching the pinnacle of a male-coded career. The judgment wasn't about her capabilities but her choices, which is seen as deeply misogynistic.
The "Myth of Man the Hunter" and the Soft Bigotry of Male Expectations
To understand this shift, it's important to look at how certain narratives are constructed. A 2023 study, "The Myth of Man the Hunter," claimed to challenge the traditional idea of men as hunters and women as gatherers, reporting evidence of women hunting in 79% of societies studied, with 33% hunting large game. This was hailed as a breakthrough, suggesting women were nearly as active in hunting as men, even in dangerous pursuits.
However, a subsequent paper by 15 hunter-gatherer researchers re-examined the work, citing sample selection bias and numerous coding errors that skewed the results. The original study's authors even stated their aim was to "shift the male hunter-female gatherer paradigm." This raises a critical question: why would a team led by a self-described feminist researcher be so motivated to portray women in male-coded ways?
This phenomenon is termed "the soft bigotry of male expectations." It's the idea that in attempts to elevate women, only achievements traditionally associated with men are deemed worthy of celebration. This is where "girl boss feminism" takes on a misogynistic undertone: anything typically masculine becomes high-status and desirable for women, while anything typically feminine becomes low-status and undesirable.
This perspective is deeply patriarchal, attempting to prove women's equality by rewriting history to make women more like men. It implies that "women did hunting too" is more emancipatory than acknowledging the critical importance of gathering, childcare, food processing, and maintaining the social unit—roles traditionally associated with women—as equally vital to civilization. The underlying message is that hunting is high status, gathering is low status; killing is impressive, raising the people who kill is not. Male-coded contributions become the standard, and female equality is established by proving women can meet those standards, leading to a "strangely insulting compliment": "Don't worry, women are just as valuable as men. Look, they did man stuff, too."
Examples in Modern Culture
This devaluation of feminine roles is evident in various cultural expressions:
- Rachel Zegler's comments on Snow White: Her portrayal of Snow White as "dreaming about becoming the leader she knows she can be" rather than "true love" suggests a false dichotomy where leadership is pitted against falling in love, implying one is more worthy than the other.
- Nara Smith, the lifestyle influencer: Despite making a living by cooking for her family and sharing it online, she frequently receives hate from women who call her a "tradwife" and claim she's "set women back by decades." This illustrates a mindset where even cooking for one's children is seen as "betraying the cause."
The Unexamined Contempt for Femininity
"Girl boss feminism" often celebrates the female CEO, soldier, hunter, founder, and breadwinner, but has surprisingly little to say about elevating the status of motherhood, caregiving, homemaking, or emotional labor. This creates a critical question: how much supposedly pro-women rhetoric is actually built on an unexamined contempt for femininity?
While "girl boss feminism" aimed to give women equal access to opportunities, it inadvertently denied prestige to pursuits women already excelled in and which contribute significantly to society. Male-typical pursuits become something women "ascend into," while female-typical pursuits become something women "fall back on," leading to the perception that femininity is low status.
This isn't to say that one path (career, "trad life," or a mix) is inherently better, as choices are individual and influenced by preferences, economics, and age. However, prestige seems to flow in only one direction from certain corners of supposedly pro-women thought.
The Hypocrisy of Criticizing Men for Feminine Traits
The "soft bigotry of male expectations" is further revealed when those holding "girl boss feminist" beliefs criticize men for behaving in stereotypically feminine ways. For example, a tweet that debases a man for being in a position considered feminine accidentally reveals a belief that femininity itself is degrading. As one reply noted, "It speaks more to your perception of your own worth than it does about his." If becoming more feminine makes a man seem weaker, it exposes a negative view of femininity. This eagerness to insult men inadvertently insults women and potentially themselves.
Reclaiming the Value of Feminine Choices
Historically, women had limited options beyond homemaking and raising children. While this lack of choice was unfair, it shouldn't mean that in a modern world with alternatives, a woman who chooses a typically feminine path should be seen as less valuable. The idea that all stay-at-home moms are "rubes conned into domestic servitude by the patriarchy" is not an equality-informed way to judge the life choices and preferences of a vast number of women.
Instead of trying to prove women can participate in masculine-coded contributions, why doesn't "girl boss feminism" elevate women by increasing the status of feminine-coded contributions? There is something truly revealing about a movement that treats women entering male roles as progress, women entering female roles as pitiful, and men entering female roles as punchlines.
As Timothy Leary famously said, "Women who seek to be equal with men lack ambition." The goal for future generations of women should be loftier than simply emulating men's lives. Regardless of their choices, women should be valued exactly as they are, and their choices deemed worthy as long as they are truly their own.
Takeaways
- The article argues that 'girl boss feminism' often turns misogynistic by praising only traditionally male achievements and devaluing feminine roles such as caregiving, homemaking, and emotional labor.
- It cites a case where a high‑powered executive who left her tech job to be a full‑time mother faced subtle disdain, illustrating how choosing a feminine path can be judged as less valuable.
- The concept of the 'soft bigotry of male expectations' is introduced, describing the bias that elevates male‑coded contributions while treating female‑coded ones as low status, even within feminist discourse.
- The article critiques recent research like the 'Myth of Man the Hunter' for being driven by a desire to rewrite history to match male standards, exposing methodological flaws and a feminist agenda to prove women can do male‑coded activities.
- It calls for a reorientation of feminism that raises the prestige of traditionally feminine activities rather than forcing women to emulate men, asserting that true equality respects and values all choices.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the 'soft bigotry of male expectations' as described in the article?
The 'soft bigotry of male expectations' refers to the subtle bias that celebrates achievements traditionally associated with men while dismissing or devaluing contributions linked to femininity. In the article it explains how feminist rhetoric can unintentionally uphold male‑coded standards, making female‑coded roles appear low‑status even when they are essential to society.
Why does the article claim the 'Myth of Man the Hunter' study is biased?
The article says the 'Myth of Man the Hunter' study is biased because its sample selection favored societies where women hunted and it contained coding errors that inflated female hunting rates. It argues the authors deliberately aimed to overturn the male‑hunter paradigm, turning the research into a feminist‑driven narrative rather than an objective anthropological finding.
Who is Chris Williamson on YouTube?
Chris Williamson is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
why would
team led by a self-described feminist researcher be so motivated to portray women in male-coded ways?
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.