Racism in German Churches: Clergy Stories and Anti‑Racism Efforts
Racism is deeply embedded within the church, much like asbestos in walls, according to Protestant theologian Sarah Vecera. While the church often positions itself on the right side of history, easily identifying external discrimination, it frequently overlooks the racism within its own structures. This internal struggle is particularly evident in a diverse, migration-shaped society where a predominantly white, highly educated church struggles to evolve and remain relevant.
The Church's Internal Struggle with Racism
Sarah Vecera, an author, podcaster, and educational consultant specializing in anti-racism and the church, highlights this issue in her book, "How Did Jesus Become White?" She emphasizes that while the church was a positive influence in her youth, it's crucial to address the discrimination that exists within it, even if not officially condoned.
Vecera, who grew up in a white church environment in the Ruhr region, recalls not seeing herself represented in children's Bibles. Characters like David were depicted as blond, white boys, and attempts at diversity often reproduced racist stereotypes, portraying non-white individuals as exotic while white individuals were "normal." The only people who looked like her in church contexts were children on donation posters.
To challenge these perceptions, Vecera visits a children's group at a Catholic parish in Cologne Vingst. She asks the children what Jesus looked like, receiving responses like "light skin and curly hair, brown hair and a white robe." When she points out that Jesus was from Bethlehem and likely looked more like people from that region—perhaps more like her than a white child—the children consider the possibility. Vecera laments that Jesus, who was not white, is consistently depicted as such in nativity scenes and children's Bibles, missing an opportunity to connect with diverse children. She believes God loves everyone and wants all to thrive, advocating for a children's Bible where Jesus reflects the diversity of the children.
Vecera also notes how children learn societal roles early on: "Who stands at the front of the church at the pulpit? A white man. Who cleans the toilets? A Black woman." This shapes a worldview through a racial lens, impacting even white individuals, and she stresses the need to remove these lenses collectively for change to occur.
Experiences of Racism Among Clergy
Germany faces a shortage of young priests and pastors, leading the Catholic Church to recruit from the Global Catholic Church. Nearly a third of all Catholic priests in the Diocese of Münster now come from abroad.
Uchenna Aba, a priest from Nigeria who came to the Lower Rhine region ten years ago, has experienced people questioning his training or the validity of his baptism. Thaddeus Eze, another Nigerian priest in the Diocese of Münster and spokesperson for African priests in the Global Catholic Church, also recounts racist prejudice. He describes situations on trains where people avoid sitting next to him unless no other seats are available, attributing this to a "deep-rooted fear of strangers."
Abdullah Alamad, a Syrian refugee who found church asylum, also experienced this fear of the unfamiliar. He recently had his asylum application approved, marking a moment of freedom. Thaddeus Eze emphasizes the church's role in bringing people together and helping them integrate, drawing on his own experience of being welcomed despite initial difficulties.
Aba and Eze, though well-integrated, faced challenges adapting to German culture and language. Aba recalls being told to sing quietly during a service, a stark contrast to the joyful, enthusiastic worship he was accustomed to. Eze views mass as a celebration, a loving encounter with God, not a formal one.
However, not all priests from the global Catholic church have positive experiences. Father Egide Muziazia, a fellow priest, faced severe racist attacks, including slurs at the supermarket and people crossing the street to avoid him. His neighbor, Hans-Jörgen Wernicke, witnessed an attack and encouraged Muziazia to speak out. The Diocese of Münster publicly supported Muziazia, with Auxiliary Bishop Rolf Lohmann expressing deep concern that such incidents occur among Christians who believe in human equality before God. The trauma led Muziazia to fear for his safety, even using a back garden entrance to his home.
Local residents in Elten, Muziazia's parish, expressed mixed reactions. Some attributed the hostility to conservative older people, suggesting local priests might be better. Others were deeply upset, emphasizing that everyone is equal regardless of background and condemning the insults and racist comments. A demonstration in Elten showed majority support for the priest, and his friends from the Global Catholic Church offered solidarity. Muziazia eventually left the parish and started a new life in Münster due to the severity of the attacks.
Addressing Systemic Racism in the Church
Racism, whether open, institutional, or structural, is pervasive. Protestant theologian Nathalie Eleyth argues that structural racism is deeply embedded in society, and thus in the church. This manifests in language, imagery in sermons, and a lack of diversity and representation for people of color in leadership positions. The EKD (Protestant Church in Germany) leadership, for example, is overwhelmingly white and highly educated, with no Black people in its highest decision-making body, the Synod.
This lack of representation is concerning, especially as the church loses members. Eleyth believes people of color bring strength and energy needed for change, and productive disagreement can lead to transformation. The goal is not to abolish the church but to make it a welcoming place for everyone, reflecting society's diversity. With almost 30% of people in Germany having a migration background, the church needs structures that include non-white Germans in shaping its institutions.
Anti-Racism Initiatives and Education
The Protestant Church in Germany is beginning to address racism at the highest levels. EKD council chairwoman, Bishop Kirsten Fehrs, found an anti-racism workshop to be an "eye-opener," realizing the extent of lingering racist thought patterns. She believes personal reflection is crucial for systemic change.
Sarah Vecera and Thea Hummel from the United Evangelical Mission regularly conduct anti-racism workshops in churches. These workshops aim to create safe spaces for discussing behavioral patterns and developing empathy, though confronting one's own biases can be painful. Attendees share their prejudices openly, seeking ways to overcome them, such as through increased opportunities for interaction.
Mike Agboola, an attendee, highlights the daily experience of racism, including phrases like "Go back to where you come from." The workshops examine images that subconsciously shape impressions, such as old missionary donation boxes depicting "pure racism" or modern advertising using racist stereotypes. They also analyze images portraying white people as saviors and Black people as those in need of saving, reinforcing the idea that non-white people are less civilized and require help rather than being seen as equals. Recognizing these influences, though uncomfortable, presents a significant opportunity for change.
Confronting the past also means addressing colonialism and missionary history. Nicolas Moumouni, officer for intercultural church development at the Protestant North Church, campaigns for remembrance that honors not only German soldiers but also the victims of colonial wars. He lights two candles in St. Michael's Church—one for German soldiers and one for the thousands of anonymous victims—questioning the one-sided culture of remembrance and the church's role in historical injustices.
Nathalie Eleyth advocates for racism to be a mandatory part of theology studies, ensuring future teachers are aware of societal diversity. Her seminars on racism and postcolonial theology are popular, addressing not only racial discrimination but also sexism and hostility towards queer people within the church. She challenges the notion that people can no longer "say everything," questioning whether this is a legitimate restriction of free speech or a desire to express discriminatory views without challenge.
A Vision for an Inclusive Church
Catholic Auxiliary Bishop Rolf Lohmann emphasizes the importance of engaging with all of God's people to shape the church's future, making confronting reality a key part of ministry.
Uchenna Aba and Thaddeus Eze host Bishop Lohmann, who acknowledges the energy and cultural elements they bring to services, celebrating the mixing and enrichment of cultures. Lohmann challenges the fear and uncertainty projected onto foreigners, recognizing them as contributing members of the community whose children will grow up in Germany. He stresses the need for the church to be louder and clearer in its beliefs against racist ideas.
In Essen, Sarah Vecera, with musicians Judy Bailey and Patrick Depuhl, uses music and conversation to foster compassion. She notes that racism thrives on ignorance and that questions like "Where are you really from?" can be hurtful if trust isn't established. She dreams of a church where everyone connects, opens their hearts, and speaks honestly.
Nicolas Moumouni, Sarah Vecera, and Nathalie Eleyth are all involved in the EKD's Anti-Racism Network Committee, led by Eleyth. This committee aims to develop the first theological position paper on racism and anti-racism for the EKD, including concrete measures to make the church a safe and welcoming place for everyone. Recent actions include anti-racism training for church leadership and the election of Yared Dibaba, a person of color, to the Synod and its finance committee—a concrete step towards diverse leadership.
The dream for the church is a shelter, a home for everyone, where Black women, people with disabilities, queer people, and those living in poverty are at the forefront. It's a dream of a diverse, living community that speaks honestly, builds friendships, and is open and unafraid—a family where all are equal.
Takeaways
- Protestant theologian Sarah Vecera compares the church’s embedded racism to asbestos, noting that while churches condemn external discrimination they often ignore their own white‑centric biases.
- Vecera’s observations of children’s Bibles and nativity scenes reveal that portraying Jesus as white reinforces exclusion and prevents diverse children from seeing themselves reflected in faith narratives.
- Nigerian priests Uchenna Aba and Thaddeus Eze recount everyday racism in Germany—from questioning their baptism to being avoided on public transport—highlighting the personal toll of institutional bias within the Catholic Church.
- Anti‑racism workshops led by Vecera, Thea Hummel, and others are prompting church leaders, such as Bishop Kirsten Fehrs, to confront subconscious stereotypes and consider structural reforms like diversifying synod representation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Sarah Vecera argue that depicting Jesus as white harms diverse children?
Vecera says that showing Jesus as white creates a visual norm that excludes non‑white children, making it harder for them to identify with the central figure of their faith and reinforcing the idea that whiteness equals holiness.
What is meant by 'structural racism' in the context of the German Protestant church?
In this context, structural racism refers to the entrenched patterns—such as predominantly white leadership, lack of people of color in decision‑making bodies, and racially biased imagery in sermons—that systematically marginalize non‑white members, even when no overt prejudice is expressed.
Who is DW Documentary on YouTube?
DW Documentary is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.