French corporate bonds now beat government yields – key takeaways

•

 31 min video

•

 9 min read

YouTube video ID: Uje_KSCzJJc

Source: YouTube video by Patrick Boyle — Watch original video

PDF

If you had €100 to lend this week and wanted a safe borrower, the bond market would suggest lending to companies like L'Oréal, Air Liquide, LVMH, or Sanofi, or even a wide selection of triple-B rated companies, rather than the French Republic. These companies can now borrow money more cheaply than France, as can Italy and Greece. This situation is particularly embarrassing for French officials who have spent recent weeks asserting that France is not Greece. Bloomberg reports that approximately €25 billion of French high-grade corporate bonds, or 38% of the market, now trade at lower yields than French government debt of similar maturity, up from just €12 billion at the start of the year.

France's Shifting Financial Standing

Traditionally, a government is considered the safest borrower in its own country because it can raise taxes or print money if needed. However, France cannot print its own money, having handed that power to the European Central Bank (ECB) in 1999. While it can still raise taxes, investors have recently begun to reconsider France's reliability. French 10-year borrowing costs recently neared 5%, the highest in almost 25 years. The spread over German bonds, a key indicator of investor nervousness, briefly exceeded 1.5 percentage points, the widest since 2011. This indicates a significant downgrade in France's financial perception within the Eurozone.

Simultaneously, high school students across France have been protesting teacher shortages, overcrowded classrooms, and dilapidated school buildings. While most protests have been peaceful, some have involved setting fires and led to over 6,000 arrests, mostly of teenagers. These protests highlight a demand for increased spending on schools, contrasting sharply with the bond market's desire for reduced government spending overall.

The "FROGS" Acronym and France's Debt Challenge

During the Euro crisis, troubled economies were collectively known as "PIGS" (Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece, Spain). Now, France has been given its own acronym: "FROGS," standing for "French Oversized Government and Social Security," coined by the Paris research firm Rexicode. This reflects growing concerns about France's fiscal situation.

The current global economic climate contributes to France's challenges. For the past decade, borrowing was nearly free, and governments took advantage. Today, the median 10-year government bond in the rich world yields around 4%, the highest in over 15 years. This rise in borrowing costs is attributed to several factors:

  • AI Investment Boom: Major hyperscalers like Alphabet, Amazon, Meta, Microsoft, and Oracle are projected to spend $800 billion on capital investment this year and $1.2 trillion next year. They are increasingly borrowing to fund data centers, issuing $230 billion in bonds this year alone, double last year's total. This draws from the same global pool of savings governments borrow from, and these AI companies are not price-sensitive borrowers.
  • War in Ukraine: The conflict has driven up crude oil prices by about 40%, contributing to persistent inflation. This has prompted central banks, including the Federal Reserve and the ECB, to raise interest rates, further increasing borrowing costs for governments.

When interest rates rise, indebted governments face a critical test. If economic growth outpaces the interest rate on debt, the debt shrinks as a share of national income. However, if the interest rate is higher than the growth rate, debt grows relative to the economy unless taxes are raised or spending is cut. This is known as the R minus G dynamic.

While some countries are managing this test (e.g., the US with its reserve currency and strong growth, Japan with domestic debt ownership and rising inflation), France faces unique difficulties. It doesn't issue a reserve currency, isn't experiencing an AI boom, imports most of its oil and gas, and hasn't yet had a "Liz Truss moment" (referring to the UK's bond market crisis in 2022). French borrowing costs were about 2 percentage points above nominal GDP growth in the second quarter, the widest gap in the rich world, indicating that French debt is growing faster than its economy.

France's Fiscal Outlook and Political Challenges

A report commissioned by the French government in May projected that, based on current policies, the deficit would reach 6.8% of GDP by 2030, debt would exceed 130% of GDP, and the annual interest bill would increase by €10 billion. To stabilize debt, France would need to save approximately €125 billion annually by 2032. This calculation assumed a 10-year borrowing rate of 3.7%, which has since risen to about 4.9%. Ben Hall of the FT estimates the required annual savings have now increased to €140 billion.

Prime Minister Gabriel Attal's 2027 budget proposes €43 billion in spending cuts and tax rises for one year. However, this level of savings needs to be sustained annually until 2032, and Attal's government lacks a parliamentary majority. ING economists believe even the full implementation of his plan would not stabilize the debt.

A key issue, according to the commission, is the French state's tendency to act as an insurer of last resort, with emergency measures often remaining in place long after the crisis has passed, creating a "ratchet effect." While raising taxes is an option, France's tax burden is already 44% of GDP, the highest in the Eurozone, compared to an OECD average of 34%. Public consent for taxation is reportedly weakening due to a perception of declining public services despite high taxes.

Spending cuts are another avenue, but politically challenging. Pensions account for almost a quarter of public spending, and French workers retire earlier with more generous terms than in most rich countries. While not legally untouchable, pension reforms are politically sensitive. Attal's budget proposes freezing the most generous state pensions, facing opposition. Defense spending, conversely, is ring-fenced.

The student protests highlight the dilemma: while students demand more spending on education, the government's budget cuts 1,588 teaching posts, citing falling pupil numbers. This timing has been criticized, with one student noting the increase in military budget while education faces cuts. Student unions estimate their demands would cost €10 billion.

The Italian Paradox: Why Italy Borrows More Cheaply

Despite France's struggles, Italy, with higher debt, borrows more cheaply. Italy's net debt is almost 130% of GDP, compared to France's just under 120%. This counterintuitive situation is not due to newfound tax compliance in Italy, as evidenced by widespread tax evasion schemes (e.g., registering cars in Poland to avoid Italian taxes and insurance).

The key difference lies in the primary balance, which is a government's budget before interest payments. Italy runs a primary surplus, meaning it collects more in taxes than it spends on running the country (excluding interest payments). It has done so for most years since the early 1990s, learning from past crises. Its overall deficit (including interest) is expected to fall below 3% of GDP this year.

France, however, runs a primary deficit of 2.9% of GDP. This means that even without any debt or interest payments, France would still be borrowing to cover its operational costs. It has run a primary deficit every year since 2002 and hasn't balanced its overall budget since 1974. While Italy faces its own risks (upcoming elections, populist politics, rising deficit projections), the bond market perceives that Italy has already undergone its crisis and demonstrated an ability to run a surplus, whereas France has not. The political cost of fiscal adjustment in France remains very high.

Political Responses and the ECB's Role

French political leaders offer varied solutions. President Macron's business-friendly reforms since 2017 have seen national debt grow by over a trillion euros, largely due to pandemic and energy crisis protections. The current Prime Minister is struggling to pass his budget without a majority.

Marine Le Pen of the National Rally, a frontrunner for the next presidential election, has recently advocated for fiscal discipline, proposing a constitutional golden rule to cap debt at 60% of GDP and cut the deficit by half a percentage point annually, backed by €140 billion in savings by 2032. While the bond market reacted positively, economists are skeptical given her simultaneous proposals to cut VAT on energy and food and lower the retirement age.

Jean-Luc Mélenchon, another presidential contender, has suggested more radical solutions, such as converting French bonds held by the central bank into perpetual zero-coupon debt that France would never repay. Experts warn this would merely shift costs to the central bank and damage France's credibility in the bond market. Historically, France has a precedent for debt write-offs, such as the "bankruptcy of the 2/3" in 1797.

The bond market is currently weighing these options: a minority government struggling with its budget, a frontrunner promising fiscal discipline alongside costly social measures, and a rival proposing a debt "bonfire." This explains why investors demand higher returns to lend to France than to Germany.

The ECB's Dilemma

The ECB faces pressure to intervene if France's financial situation worsens. Commerzbank's chief economist, George Kramer, outlines four potential steps for the ECB: 1. Sound less hawkish on interest rates. 2. Verbal intervention, declaring readiness to use emergency tools. 3. Stop shrinking its balance sheet and reinvest maturing bonds, tilting reinvestments towards France. 4. Activate the Transmission Protection Instrument (TPI).

The TPI, created in 2022, allows the ECB to buy a country's bonds with no size limit if market moves are "unwarranted and disorderly." However, a country must be following "sound and sustainable fiscal policies" to qualify. France is currently under the EU's excessive deficit procedure, which complicates its eligibility. While the ECB is unlikely to let France collapse, using the TPI for a government with a 5.4% deficit and budget difficulties would be controversial, particularly in Germany.

ECB President Christine Lagarde has previously faced criticism for comments that caused Italian borrowing costs to jump. With high energy prices and persistent inflation, the ECB has raised rates twice this year, and further hikes are possible, making France's debt more expensive. Lagarde has indicated that higher bond yields are already helping to slow the economy, suggesting the bond market is doing some of the ECB's work.

This situation creates a "game of chicken": countries are expected to fix their budgets before the ECB buys their bonds. However, the European Union cannot survive without France. If a populist French president refused to cut spending and dared the ECB to let French bonds collapse, the president would likely win, as France is "not Greece" (which capitulated in 2015 when the ECB capped emergency funding).

The Slow Squeeze

The situation in France is described as a "slow squeeze" rather than a sudden collapse. France benefits from high household savings, reliable tax collection, and a stable banking system. Its biggest protection is the euro, which shields it from a currency run. In 1968, a general strike led to a significant wage increase, causing money to leave the country and forcing a devaluation of the franc. With the euro, pressure builds more slowly: a widening spread over Germany, an interest bill that steadily consumes more of the budget, and a frequent turnover of prime ministers.

The bond market is currently waiting. Parliament will decide on the €43 billion budget package. Moody's is set to review France's credit rating, and the ECB will meet on October 29th to discuss interest rates. If nothing changes, France's debt will continue to grow, and its interest bill will rise by approximately €10 billion annually, based on July's interest rates. The bond market will continue to update its league table, reflecting these ongoing challenges.

  Takeaways

  • French high‑grade corporate bonds now trade at lower yields than comparable French government bonds, a reversal from earlier in the year.
  • The shift reflects rising French borrowing costs, with 10‑year yields near 5% and spreads over German Bunds widening to over 1.5 percentage points, the widest since 2011.
  • France’s fiscal challenges are amplified by a primary deficit of about 2.9% of GDP and a projected debt‑to‑GDP ratio above 130% by 2030, requiring annual savings of roughly €140 billion to stabilise debt.
  • Italy, despite higher debt, enjoys cheaper borrowing because it runs a primary surplus, highlighting the importance of primary balances over headline debt levels.
  • The ECB could intervene via tools like the Transmission Protection Instrument, but eligibility requires sound fiscal policy, leaving France dependent on domestic reforms amid political gridlock and student protests.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are French corporate bonds now yielding lower than French government bonds?

French corporate bonds now yield lower than French government bonds because investors view the companies as safer borrowers amid rising sovereign borrowing costs. The 10‑year French gilt has approached 5% and its spread over German Bunds widened to over 150 basis points, prompting investors to shift to high‑grade corporates that trade at tighter spreads.

How does Italy’s primary surplus enable cheaper borrowing compared to France’s primary deficit?

Italy can borrow more cheaply than France because it runs a primary surplus, meaning its tax revenues exceed non‑interest spending, whereas France runs a primary deficit of about 2.9% of GDP. A primary surplus reassures markets that Italy can service debt without relying on new borrowing, lowering its risk premium despite a higher overall debt ratio.

Who is Patrick Boyle on YouTube?

Patrick Boyle is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.

Does this page include the full transcript of the video?

Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.

Helpful resources related to this video

If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.

Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.

Full transcript is not shown on this page

This page focuses on the summary and original notes. For full verification, refer to the original YouTube video.

PDF