U.S. Housing Shortage: Affordable Units, Hurdles, Productivity
The United States is facing a significant housing shortage, a complex and localized issue that has evolved from being concentrated in specific regions to a nationwide concern. While historically, high housing prices and restrictive zoning were primarily problems in areas like New England, New York, and California, the last decade has seen these issues spread across the country.
The Role of the Great Financial Crisis and Overbuilding
Contrary to some beliefs, the "overbuilding" of homes before the Great Financial Crisis (GFC) is not considered a primary cause of the current housing shortage. In the decade following the GFC, there was a period of low home construction. However, this was largely offset by the availability of vacant homes generated during the 2000s boom. The current problem is less about an absolute shortage of houses and more about a shortage of affordable housing in areas where jobs and people are concentrated. Building affordable housing in remote areas without economic opportunities is not a viable solution.
The Challenge of Construction Costs
A major hurdle in addressing the housing crisis is the escalating cost of construction. In 2023, an initiative in Boston explored using tax abatements to stimulate home construction, particularly for 23,000 approved units that had not yet broken ground. The study found that tax abatements had a surprisingly small effect and were prohibitively expensive for the city. The primary driver preventing construction was the high cost of building. Construction costs surged during the pandemic and have not decreased, making it difficult for new projects to be financially viable, even with lower interest rates. This issue is prevalent across the country.
Seeking Solutions: Zoning and Productivity
There is a general consensus that more can be done on the zoning front, as many existing restrictions offer minimal benefits while imposing significant costs. However, there is no single "silver bullet" solution.
A key area for long-term housing cost reduction is improving productivity in home construction. Research, including a paper co-authored by Chad Syverson and Austan Goolsbee (President of the Chicago Fed), highlights that there has been virtually no productivity growth in construction over the last 50 years. This stands in stark contrast to other sectors of the economy, which have seen substantial productivity gains, often doubling.
Addressing Productivity in Construction
The lack of productivity growth in construction means that the same number of workers produce roughly the same number of houses as they did decades ago. This issue is distinct from the quantity of available workers, though the supply of appropriate labor and training for construction workers are also factors. The focus needs to be on enabling workers to produce more efficiently.
The dream of factory-built housing has existed for generations, yet construction remains largely a labor-intensive, on-site activity. While there have been improvements like nail guns, a construction site today is not fundamentally different from one a century ago, unlike manufacturing industries that have embraced automation and significantly reduced on-site labor. The question remains how to introduce similar levels of innovation and efficiency, potentially through robotics or advanced prefabricated housing techniques, to make home construction more productive and ultimately lower housing costs.
Takeaways
- The housing shortage in the United States has shifted from a regional problem to a nationwide lack of affordable homes where jobs are concentrated.
- Overbuilding before the Great Financial Crisis is not the main cause; the post‑crisis dip in construction was partly offset by vacant homes from the 2000s boom.
- Rising construction costs, amplified by pandemic‑era price spikes, are now the primary barrier to building new housing, even when interest rates fall.
- Zoning reforms can help, but the most impactful long‑term fix is boosting productivity in home construction, which has seen virtually no growth in the past five decades.
- Introducing automation, robotics, or advanced prefabrication could transform the labor‑intensive building process and lower housing prices, though such innovations have yet to be widely adopted.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is overbuilding before the Great Financial Crisis not seen as the main driver of today's housing shortage?
Overbuilding before the GFC is not seen as the main driver because the subsequent decade saw very low new construction, yet the surplus of vacant homes from the 2000s boom offset much of that excess supply. The current shortage is therefore more about a lack of affordable units in high‑job‑density areas than an absolute housing deficit.
How does the lack of productivity growth in construction impact housing affordability?
The lack of productivity growth means workers produce roughly the same number of houses today as they did decades ago, keeping labor costs high and limiting the number of units that can be built per dollar invested. Consequently, housing prices remain elevated because construction cannot become cheaper through efficiency gains.
Who is Bloomberg Originals on YouTube?
Bloomberg Originals is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.