Fire Escapes: History, Economics, and Why They Disappeared

•

 18 min video

•

 7 min read

YouTube video ID: awV7FP9sAHE

Source: YouTube video by Practical Engineering — Watch original video

PDF

The concept of fire escapes emerged from a simple necessity: providing an alternative, protected evacuation route from tall buildings when the main stairwell is compromised by fire. While escaping a one or two-story building might involve a minor injury from a window jump, taller structures in early American cities presented a more complex challenge. High-profile fires in factories, tenements, offices, and theaters were common, leading to the seemingly obvious solution of bolting metal staircases to the outside of buildings, with landings below windows on each floor.

Fire escapes have become an iconic part of American urban culture, appearing in films and plays, offering city dwellers a place for fresh air, and defining the skylines of older cities. However, their effectiveness and suitability as a solution have been consistently debated. While many older buildings still maintain their original fire escapes, they are gradually disappearing, a trend that offers a compelling insight into the evolution of building codes.

The Economics of Safety and the Role of Building Codes

Building owners typically do not install safety devices like fire escapes purely out of altruism. The economic realities of real estate make it difficult to justify the costs of safety features that may never be used over a building's lifetime. Safety is rarely a primary factor in tenant purchasing decisions, meaning it doesn't significantly impact a landlord's bottom line. This "cold-hearted capitalism" is balanced by the understanding that excessive safety measures could make buildings unaffordable or unusable.

This highlights the need for a reasonable balance between no safety and overkill. The responsibility for defining this balance cannot fall on individual owners, architects, or engineers. This is the fundamental purpose of building codes: to establish a well-informed consensus on what safety measures are "worth it," representing society's collective responsibility for the safety of its built environment.

The Genesis of Fire Escapes in American Cities

Fire escapes originated from this very need. In the mid-1800s, major American cities like New York, Boston, and Chicago saw the rise of tall, multi-occupancy residential buildings, particularly tenements for poor immigrants and laborers. These buildings were designed for maximum efficiency, often featuring a single, open stairway that acted as a chimney for smoke and flames, making them dangerous fire traps.

A pivotal event occurred in February 1860 when a bakery fire in the basement of a six-story New York City tenement claimed ten lives because fire department ladders couldn't reach above the fourth floor. Public outcry led to the passage of "An Act to Provide Against Unsafe Buildings in the City of New York." This law mandated a fireproof stairway or an exterior escape route for all tenement buildings, including existing ones.

The retroactive nature of this law significantly influenced fire escape design. Reconfiguring internal stairways in existing buildings was costly, time-consuming, and often impractical. The simpler and cheaper alternative was to add external fire escapes, which became the predominant solution, despite lax enforcement of the new law.

Over time, these alternative egress requirements extended to other building types, but the initial regulations were vague about the specific form these escape structures should take. This led to a proliferation of inventive, sometimes outlandish, proposals, including:

  • Rope and chain ladders
  • Chutes
  • Slides
  • Slings
  • Baskets
  • Tubes
  • Even a "parachute hat" with rubber overshoes for a soft landing

For a period, New York City officials accepted almost any escape device. Eventually, the classic iron or steel ladder-and-balcony system became the default fire escape solution in the early 1900s, though its effectiveness remained a subject of debate.

Early Criticisms and the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire

Even as fire escapes became standardized, experts began to apply scientific scrutiny to their efficacy. Building regulations are inherently burdensome, shaping the urban environment and requiring significant investment. Therefore, it's crucial that they are well-conceived.

One of the first technical assessments was conducted by the Franklin Institute in 1881 after the Randolph Street mill fire in Philadelphia trapped 35 people. Their conclusion was that external egress paths, or bolt-on fire escapes, had "comparatively little value," asserting that properly constructed internal stairways offered the best means of escape.

This conclusion was tragically reinforced by the 1911 Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire in New York City. The Asch Building, where the factory was located, violated exit laws: inward-opening doors on narrow staircases hindered escape, and one door was reportedly locked. The building's exterior fire escape buckled under the weight of fleeing workers, leading to over 140 deaths, mostly women and girls. This disaster highlighted how fire escapes could be more detrimental than beneficial.

The Decades-Long Debate and Disadvantages

The debate over fire escapes continued for decades. One faction, including the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), argued against external fire escapes, calling them a "pitiful delusion" that contributed to panic and hindered the adoption of more functional regulations. The NFPA's 1923 model building code recommended prohibiting outside stairs as fire escapes, though this was not widely adopted.

The opposing view, often championed by insurance companies, advocated for improving existing external escapes. The 1949 National Building Code allowed exterior escapes but mandated minimum sizes, essentially transforming them into robust outdoor stairways comparable to internal ones.

However, by this time, the disadvantages of traditional fire escapes had become extensive:

  • Aesthetics: Architects disliked them for cluttering building facades and blocking views.
  • Security Risk: They provided easy access for burglars to upper floors.
  • Maintenance: They required significant upkeep to prevent rust and ensure stability.
  • Lack of Practice: Occupants rarely practiced using them, making them a less intuitive escape route in emergencies.
  • Inoperable Components: The hinged bottom stairway, often raised to prevent intrusions, could become inoperable due to lack of use.
  • Suitability: They were unsuitable for buildings like hospitals, where evacuating people through windows or down steep stairs was challenging.
  • Obstruction: Tenants often used the landings for furniture or storage, blocking the escape path.

The only remaining advantage was that they didn't consume expensive interior floor space, but this benefit was no longer sufficient.

The Shift to Modern Internal Stairways

In 1968, New York City updated its building codes, officially prohibiting exterior exits for new construction. Many other major cities followed suit. The solution that replaced them was precisely what the Franklin Institute had proposed nearly a century earlier: reliance on internal stairways.

The Franklin Institute's prescient 1881 quote stated: "As a general rule, applicable to all buildings, the main reliance should be placed upon stairways in daily use, for the obvious reason that the occupants of a building instinctively seek such an escape in case of fire, that they are familiar with it, and that, being in daily use, it is reasonably certain to be unobstructed and to have the approaches to it clear." They further suggested that stairways be enclosed in brick, built of incombustible materials, and fitted with self-closing doors to keep out smoke. This description perfectly matches the modern tower stairway found in tall buildings today.

Modern safety features, though less conspicuous than external iron assemblies, are significantly safer. This consensus was reached through decades of gradual improvements, including:

  • Safer consumer products
  • Fire-rated building materials
  • Sprinklers
  • Alarms
  • Reliable air-conditioning systems that enable windowless, interior, smoke-proof stair towers

The Enduring Impact and Unintended Consequences of Building Codes

Building codes possess a unique momentum. They typically apply only to new construction, meaning their benefits are realized years later. Once established, and as industries adapt, there's significant resistance to their removal. This makes it challenging to foresee the long-term repercussions of specific codes.

An example of unintended consequences is the current cost of elevators in the U.S., which are at least three times more expensive than in other developed countries. This is partly due to a code amendment, proposed by a fire inspector in Glendale, Arizona, requiring elevators to accommodate a horizontal stretcher. The proposal erroneously claimed no cost impact and slipped through without close scrutiny. The result is that U.S. elevators are significantly larger, leading many building owners to opt for walk-up designs instead, ultimately reducing accessibility for people with mobility issues—the very group the rule was intended to help.

Similarly, New York City's 1860 fire egress law, by applying to existing buildings, inadvertently cemented bolt-on external retrofits as the prevailing solution for nearly 150 years. Writing building regulations is a complex process with rarely a single "right" answer, only tradeoffs that ripple through space, time, and the economy. While old iron fire escapes hold a certain nostalgic charm, their eventual disappearance is a testament to safer, more effective building practices.

  Takeaways

  • Fire escapes were introduced in the mid‑1800s as cheap external egress for tall tenements after a deadly 1860 bakery fire prompted New York’s first fire‑escape law.
  • Early assessments, such as the Franklin Institute’s 1881 report, argued that internal stairways were far safer than bolt‑on external escapes, a view later confirmed by tragedies like the 1911 Triangle Shirtwaist fire where the exterior escape collapsed.
  • Economic pressures kept owners from installing safety features voluntarily, so building codes became the primary mechanism to mandate fire‑escape provisions and later to phase them out in favor of interior stair towers.
  • Over time, fire escapes were criticized for aesthetic ugliness, security risks, high maintenance, and impracticality, leading many cities to ban new external exits after 1968 and replace them with enclosed, fire‑rated stairwells.
  • The legacy of historic codes shows how retroactive regulations can lock in suboptimal solutions for decades, illustrating the broader challenge of unintended consequences in building‑code evolution.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the 1860 New York bakery fire trigger legislation requiring exterior fire escapes?

The bakery fire killed ten people because fire‑department ladders could not reach the upper floors, exposing the lack of safe egress in tall tenements. Public outrage forced New York to pass “An Act to Provide Against Unsafe Buildings,” mandating fire‑proof stairways or external escape routes for all tenements, including existing structures.

What was the Franklin Institute’s 1881 assessment of bolt‑on fire escapes?

The Institute concluded that external bolt‑on fire escapes offered “comparatively little value” compared with properly constructed internal stairways, arguing that daily‑used staircases were more reliable because occupants were familiar with them and they were less likely to be obstructed or fail during a fire.

Who is Practical Engineering on YouTube?

Practical Engineering is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.

Does this page include the full transcript of the video?

Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.

Helpful resources related to this video

If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.

Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.

Full transcript is not shown on this page

This page focuses on the summary and original notes. For full verification, refer to the original YouTube video.

PDF