Why US Home Prices Remain Stable Despite Affordability Crisis

•

 20 min video

•

 5 min read

YouTube video ID: EhbkCW3iTvA

Source: YouTube video by How Money Works — Watch original video

PDF

Despite rising interest rates, increased housing stock, corporate investors exiting the market, and a general struggle with affordability, home prices in America have not crashed, unlike in many other countries. This resilience is puzzling given that sellers now outnumber buyers by the widest margin in history, and net immigration has significantly decreased, reducing potential demand.

The Affordability Gap

Housing affordability is at an all-time low. The median household income required to purchase a home is $126,500, while the actual median household income is $86,500, creating a $40,000 gap. This gap is wider than before the 2008 mortgage crisis and doesn't account for rising costs like insurance and maintenance.

Reasons for Market Resilience

1. Circular Finance and Developer Shenanigans

A significant factor is the use of circular finance by property developers. Developers, who rely on debt facilities to fund construction, are facing high interest rates (10-13% for construction loans) and a decline in buyers. To manage this, some developers are engaging in questionable practices:

  • Self-Purchasing Properties: Companies like Lenar have allegedly used spin-off entities (e.g., Milrose Properties) to buy their unsold homes at inflated prices (around 13% higher than market value). This creates an illusion of strong market activity and helps developers meet sales targets.
    • Note on Hunterbrook: The investigation into Lenar was conducted by Hunterbrook, an investigative journalism outlet with an attached hedge fund. This structure means they profit from shorting companies they expose, raising potential conflicts of interest, though it also incentivizes accurate reporting.
  • Sweetened Financing Deals: Homebuilders are offering generous financing, including interest rates as low as 0.99% for the first year, then subsidized to 3.99% fixed for 30 years. While this represents a significant loss over the loan's life (e.g., $60,000 on a $400,000 mortgage), it allows builders to claim full market value for homes and attract buyers limited by monthly repayments. Lenar, for instance, spent an average of $51,000 per home on incentives last quarter, about 12% of the sale price.
    • This tactic is similar to practices seen in other countries, like Chinese developers offering gold bars to circumvent price drop bans.
  • Private Credit Firms: Private credit firms, such as Blackstone's dedicated homebuilder lending arm, are increasingly filling financing gaps for Sun Belt developments, further propping up the market.

2. Statistical Misrepresentation and Market Segmentation

Tracking the real estate market is complex due to regional variations and different data sets:

  • Conflicting Data: The median sales price of new homes is down nearly 10% since 2022, according to Fed data. However, the S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller Home Price Index, which tracks existing homes, is up 10% over the same period.
    • New vs. Existing Homes: The "new houses sold" data tracks only new constructions, while Case-Shiller tracks existing homes from their second sale onward.
    • Falling New Home Prices: Despite developer incentives, new home prices are still falling, indicating the severity of the underlying market weakness.
    • Rising Existing Home Prices: Existing homes appear to be rising in price, partly because owners with low fixed interest rates are less desperate to sell.
  • "New Homes Cheaper Than Used Homes" Misconception: Headlines suggesting new homes are cheaper than used ones (e.g., median existing home at $428,000 vs. new at $394,000 in August) are misleading.
    • Product Mix: Most new homes being built and sold are lower-cost starter homes (sales under $300,000 are up 30% in two years). In contrast, existing homes being sold are often larger, more established properties transacting between existing homeowners who are less affected by high interest rates.
    • First-Time Buyers: First-time homebuyers now account for a record low of 21% of sales, with the average age of entry being 40.
    • Regional Disparities: Markets like New York and San Francisco have seen a resurgence in existing property values (e.g., New York prices up 5.8%, San Francisco median at $1.7 million). This is partly due to people moving back to established commercial centers after pandemic-era moves to lower-tax states like Florida, Texas, and Nevada, where much of the new construction occurred.
    • Tax Incentives: State-level income and property tax differences in the U.S. (e.g., California's 13.3% top rate vs. Nevada's 0%) significantly influence migration patterns, unlike in countries like Australia or Canada where tax differences are less pronounced.
    • Housing Stock Diversity: The U.S. has a greater variety of individual markets and a higher proportion of detached houses (nearly two-thirds of housing stock) compared to countries like Germany or the UK, allowing for more localized market dynamics.
  • Quality Concerns: Many newly built homes from large developers face litigation for construction defects, making some buyers wary and shrinking the effective market for new homes.

3. Unique American Market Characteristics

Several structural differences in the U.S. housing market contribute to its resilience:

  • 30-Year Fixed-Rate Mortgages: Unlike most other major markets where fixed terms are typically a maximum of 10 years or variable rates are common, 30-year fixed mortgages in the U.S. insulate many homeowners from interest rate hikes. This disincentivizes selling for those locked into low rates.
  • Property Tax Basis: Property taxes in many U.S. markets are based on the original purchase price, not the current market value. This means an existing homeowner could pay significantly less in taxes and repayments than a new buyer for the same property.
    • The typical mortgage holder pays $1,291/month, while buying the median home today costs $2,236/month. In Los Angeles, it's $2,960 vs. $5,792. This drastic increase in monthly payments makes the same property inaccessible to many previous buyers.
  • Low Sales Volume: The U.S. sold 4.1 million houses last year, a 30-year low. This low transaction volume means that while prices might not be crashing, the market is largely frozen, with fewer homes changing hands.

Future Outlook

While it might be satisfying to see developers and institutional investors struggle, this situation could lead to less home construction in the future. Housing completions are already down 27% year-over-year. If interest rates eventually decline, this reduced supply could quickly lead to another market gap, making homes even less affordable.

  Takeaways

  • US home prices have not collapsed because existing‑home values are buoyed by owners locked into low‑rate 30‑year mortgages, reducing selling pressure despite a widening affordability gap.
  • Developers are using circular finance tactics such as self‑purchasing homes through spin‑offs and offering deep financing incentives to fabricate sales volume and sustain price perception.
  • Data appear contradictory: new‑home prices have fallen about 10% since 2022, while the Case‑Shiller index shows a 10% rise for existing homes, reflecting divergent market segments and regional dynamics.
  • The U.S. housing market’s diversity, high proportion of detached houses, and tax‑basis differences allow localized price resilience that is not seen in more homogeneous markets like Germany or the UK.
  • With construction completions down 27% and sales volume at a 30‑year low, any future rate cuts could tighten supply further, potentially widening the affordability gap even more.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is “circular finance” and how are developers using it to prop up US home prices?

Circular finance refers to developers recycling their own capital by buying back unsold homes through affiliated entities at inflated prices, creating artificial sales volume. This practice, seen with firms like Lenar, masks weak demand, helps meet sales targets, and allows builders to claim market strength while subsidizing buyer financing.

How do 30‑year fixed‑rate mortgages contribute to the stability of US existing‑home prices?

A 30‑year fixed‑rate mortgage locks borrowers into a low interest rate for the loan’s life, so homeowners with such loans have little incentive to sell when rates rise. This reduces supply of existing homes, keeping their prices from falling even as new‑home demand weakens.

Who is How Money Works on YouTube?

How Money Works is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.

Does this page include the full transcript of the video?

Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.

Helpful resources related to this video

If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.

Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.

Full transcript is not shown on this page

This page focuses on the summary and original notes. For full verification, refer to the original YouTube video.

PDF