BMW F 800 GS vs Suzuki V‑Strom 800: Best Adventure Bike
The BMW F 800 GS was chosen over other midweight adventure bikes primarily due to a combination of features, cost-effectiveness, and riding comfort, despite its relatively tall seat height.
Initial Considerations and Height Challenges
The rider, having previously owned cruisers and naked bikes, sought an adventure bike for its superior comfort over bumps. While the F 800 GS is still tall, requiring the rider to tiptoe and pick a side at stops, this compromise was deemed acceptable for the overall benefits. The difficulty in slow-speed maneuvering due to height is a known drawback.
Comparison with Other Midweight Adventure Bikes
Several options were considered, including the Suzuki V-Strom 800 and the Triumph Tiger Sport 800. The rider preferred a less sporty, more comfortable option, narrowing the choice down to the BMW F 800 GS and the Suzuki V-Strom 800, both offering a decent seat height for the rider.
The Deciding Factor: Value and Features
The Suzuki V-Strom 800 is approximately $3,000 cheaper than the BMW F 800 GS, with a base model costing around $12,000-$12,800 out the door. However, the BMW F 800 GS, purchased for $15,500 (above MSRP due to premium packages), came fully equipped with features the rider desired.
If the rider were to add all the desired features to the V-Strom 800, it would cost around $14,000. These additions would include:
- Aftermarket cruise control: The V-Strom does not come with factory cruise control, requiring a third-party installation.
- Heated grips: Essential for comfort.
- Wind protection: Handguards and other wind deflectors.
- Top bag: A significant accessory costing over $1,000.
Factoring in the cost of parts and dealer installation fees (which are not free in California), the total cost of a fully equipped V-Strom 800 would exceed that of the BMW F 800 GS.
Exclusive BMW Features
Beyond the standard additions, the BMW F 800 GS offered features not available on the V-Strom 800, even as aftermarket options:
- Keyless ignition: A highly valued feature for the rider, who previously experienced dead batteries on other bikes due to forgetting to remove the key.
- Dynamic suspension: This advanced suspension system offers superior ride quality and adjustability.
Ideal Size and Power for Commuting and Touring
The rider specifically sought a midweight adventure bike (800-900cc) for its versatility. This size provides:
- Sufficient power for freeway riding: Eliminating concerns about highway performance.
- Nimbleness for city commuting and traffic: Making it manageable in urban environments.
- Cost-effectiveness: Larger adventure bikes can approach $30,000.
Comfort and Ergonomics
Previous experiences with naked bikes (Yamaha MT-07, MT-09) revealed discomfort during longer rides (over 40 minutes) due to knee pain from the aggressive riding position. The F 800 GS's mid-controls offer a more relaxed knee bend, significantly improving comfort for extended journeys.
The suspension is another major advantage. The F 800 GS handles bumps on the freeway that would typically unseat the rider on a cruiser or naked bike. Even in "Road" mode, the power and smoothness are ample, with "Dynamic" mode offering further suspension adjustments.
Fuel Range
While the rider wished for a larger gas tank, the F 800 GS's estimated range of approximately 200 miles (based on 63 miles ridden with 162 miles remaining) is a significant improvement over previous bikes that required refueling every 100 miles.
Conclusion
The BMW F 800 GS was chosen because it offered a complete package of desired features, superior comfort, and advanced technology (like keyless ignition and dynamic suspension) at a comparable or even lower overall cost than outfitting a Suzuki V-Strom 800 with similar amenities. Despite the height challenge, the benefits of an adventure bike's comfort and versatility outweighed this drawback.
Takeaways
- The rider chose the BMW F 800 GS because its fully equipped feature set, including keyless ignition and dynamic suspension, outweighed the lower base price of the Suzuki V‑Strom 800.
- Although the V‑Strom 800 is about $3,000 cheaper initially, adding essential accessories such as cruise control, heated grips, wind protection, and a top bag pushes its total cost above that of the BMW.
- The BMW’s mid‑control ergonomics and superior suspension provide greater comfort on long rides and better handling of bumps compared to the rider’s previous cruisers and naked bikes.
- Despite its tall seat height, the F 800 GS’s 200‑mile fuel range and ample 800‑cc power make it suitable for both highway touring and city commuting.
- Overall, the BMW delivers a more complete adventure‑bike package at a comparable or lower effective cost, making the height compromise acceptable for the rider.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does the BMW F 800 GS end up cheaper than a fully equipped Suzuki V‑Strom 800 despite a higher base price?
Because the BMW comes with factory‑installed features such as keyless ignition and dynamic suspension, the rider avoids buying and installing aftermarket parts on the V‑Strom. When the cost of cruise control, heated grips, wind deflectors, a top bag and dealer labor is added, the total exceeds the BMW’s price.
What advantage does keyless ignition provide on the BMW F 800 GS?
Keyless ignition eliminates the need to insert a physical key, preventing dead‑battery lockouts that the rider experienced on other bikes. It also allows the rider to start the bike simply by touching the handlebar sensor, adding convenience and reducing the chance of forgetting to remove the key.
Who is NewbieRides Rafa on YouTube?
NewbieRides Rafa is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.