Yale, Community, and Meritocracy: Lessons from the Revolution

•

 47 min video

•

 7 min read

YouTube video ID: X1p60_okDVU

Source: YouTube video by YaleCourses — Watch original video

PDF

This lecture explores the concept of community, beginning with Yale's role during the American Revolution and then delving into the nature of imagined communities and the duties individuals owe to them. It concludes with a discussion of Michael Sandel's critique of meritocracy.

Yale and the American Revolution

Yale College, founded approximately 75 years before the Declaration of Independence, played a significant role during the American Revolution. The Declaration of Independence, famously depicted in John Trumbull's painting (a smaller version of which is in Yale's art gallery, with the larger in the U.S. Capitol), was painted almost 50 years after the event. Trumbull, son of Governor Trumbull, meticulously painted many of the founders from life. The painting shows the assembly approving the Declaration on July 4, 1776, with John Hancock presiding and the five-member drafting committee (John Adams, Roger Sherman, Robert R. Livingston, Thomas Jefferson, and Benjamin Franklin) presenting their draft. Roger Sherman, a Yale trustee and New Haven mayor, was unique in signing all four major revolutionary documents.

18th-Century Yale Characteristics

In the 18th century, Yale was: - Quasi-independent: It relied on state authority and funding but was run independently by ministers and trustees. - Closely linked to the colony: Most students were local, primarily from Connecticut, and the college received partial funding from the colony. - Educational mission: Its purpose was to educate youth for employment in both church and civil society, with roughly half entering each field. - In loco parentis: As students typically started at 16, the college acted in place of parents, with rectors and tutors holding significant authority. - Focus on godly life: Puritan educational styles influenced character and leadership education. - Curriculum: Initially traditional classical liberal arts, it evolved to include Enlightenment thinkers like Locke and Newton, and calculus, by the mid-18th century. - Collegiate structure: Students were young, tutors were recent alumni, and most students lived on campus. - Frequent conflicts: Theological disputes, such as the Great Awakening and the dismissal of a rector for Anglican prayers, were common and often had political dimensions.

Student Activism and Timothy Dwight's Vision

In 1769, Yale students demonstrated against British taxation by wearing homespun cloth at commencement, echoing later movements like Gandhi's. This act symbolized a rejection of dependence on British manufacturers.

Three weeks after the Declaration of Independence in July 1776, Timothy Dwight, a recent Yale graduate and tutor (later president), addressed the graduating class. He urged them to think beyond their local communities and colonies, emphasizing their role in "laying the foundation of American greatness." Dwight's speech highlighted: - American greatness: The continental scope of the American project, despite the colonies being along the Eastern Seaboard, with plans for expansion. - Ambiguity of immortality: A blend of religious (life after death) and secular (earthly reputation) interpretations. - Global outlook: Encouraging students to act as "citizens of a world," not just New Haven or Connecticut. - "Conflagration": A deliberate vagueness, referring to both the ongoing revolution and potentially the apocalypse.

Key Events During the Revolution

  • David Bushnell's Turtle (1775): Yale graduate David Bushnell invented the first submarine, the Turtle, which attempted to plant mines on British ships in New York Harbor but was unsuccessful. The submarine was later lost.
  • Nathan Hale (1776): A Yale alumnus, Hale was captured and hanged by the British while spying in Manhattan. His famous last words, "I only regret that I have but one life to lose for my country," are a quote from a 17th-century play. Hale is considered a forerunner of the CIA, which had origins at Yale.
  • College Closures (1777): Due to wartime difficulties—lack of subsidies, high food prices, disease (distemper, smallpox), and general danger—Yale intermittently closed. Students and their tutors were dispersed to different towns, a situation that resonated with the COVID-19 campus closure in 2020. The Yale Corporation minutes from April 1, 1777, refer to Yale as a "fixed and ancient Seat of Learning," despite its relatively young age in New Haven.
  • Battle of New Haven (Tryon's Raid, 1779): British forces from New York landed in East and West Haven with orders to burn the college. An officer claimed to have prevented the burning of the deserted college. Townspeople resisted the invasion, resulting in 27 deaths, including Naphtali Daggett, a temporary president of Yale, who died from wounds sustained while fighting.

The Theme of Community

The lecture transitions to the concept of community, particularly within a collegiate setting.

The Collegiate Community: Past and Present

  • Chaucer's Clerk: Geoffrey Chaucer's "Canterbury Tales" features a clerk of Oxford, devoted to learning and knowledge, who "gladly would he learn and gladly teach." This embodies the ideal of a college as a place for shared learning.
  • Oxford and Cambridge Influence: The architecture and structure of Yale's residential colleges, with their courtyards and dining halls, deliberately evoke the historical colleges of Oxford and Cambridge, aiming to create a "community of learning."
  • John Dewey's "Pedagogic Creed": The progressive educator emphasized the school as a social institution where a child's development is stimulated through community life.
  • Evolution of Yale's Community:
    • 1776: Approximately 150 students, 5 faculty (president, 1 professor, 3 tutors).
    • Today: Approximately 6,600 Yale College students, over 1,000 faculty in Yale College; 15,000 university students, over 5,000 university faculty. Nearly 200,000 alumni.

Defining and Engaging with Community

Attendees were asked to identify three communities they belong to and their duties to those communities. Examples included: - Religious groups: Churches, synagogues (mentioning Ezra Stiles's connections to Jewish communities and George Washington's letter on tolerance). - Language communities: French speakers. - National communities: The United States, Canada. - Local communities: Hometowns (e.g., Chicago). - Family: Nuclear and extended families. - Teams/Organizations: Running, ice hockey, rowing, basketball, residential colleges, identity-based groups (e.g., first-generation, low-income), national societies (e.g., Turkish, Scandinavian).

Duties to community: - Common civility and respect. - Fair treatment of members. - The question of owing more to members of smaller, closer communities (e.g., family) versus larger ones (e.g., nation). - Effort to improve and represent the community. - Commitment, following rules, participation. - Bringing in new members and respecting older ones (e.g., the Aurelian society).

Imagined Communities

Benedict Anderson's concept of "imagined communities" helps explain the connection people feel to large groups like nations. Anderson, who studied 19th-century nationalist movements, defined a nation as: - Imagined as limited: Even large nations have finite boundaries. - Imagined as sovereign: The concept arose during the Enlightenment and revolutions that challenged divinely-ordained rule. - Imagined as a community: Despite inequalities, a nation is conceived as a "deep horizontal comradeship."

This sense of connection extends to institutions like Yale, where alumni feel a strong bond, similar to national identity. Unlike nations, which often define membership by birth, Yale requires admission as a student or employment as faculty/staff.

Michael Sandel's Critique of Meritocracy

The lecture concludes with Michael Sandel's argument against meritocracy, particularly as it relates to higher education and societal leadership. Sandel, a liberal progressive philosopher with communitarian leanings, argues in his book "The Tyranny of Merit" and related op-eds that meritocracy is a dangerous ideology.

Key Points of Sandel's Critique:

  • Moral justification of success: In unequal societies, those at the top want to believe their success is morally justified. Meritocracy fosters the belief that winners earned their success through talent and hard work.
  • Role of luck: Sandel contends that much of individual success, especially for those admitted to elite institutions like Yale, is a product of "good luck" (e.g., circumstances of birth, support systems, available schooling).
  • Corrosive effect on democracy: When a college degree becomes a "precondition for dignified work and social esteem," it creates a "last acceptable prejudice" (credentialism) against those without diplomas. This excludes many working people from elective government and fuels political backlash, as seen in recent elections where "outsider" candidates gain traction.
  • Humility and public life: Sandel advocates for humility, recognizing the role of luck, as a civic virtue that can lead to a "less rancorous, more generous public life," moving beyond the "harsh ethic of success."

The lecture acknowledges that while Yale is a wonderful community, its admissions process raises questions about who gets in and who doesn't, and the implications of educating a select group for leadership, especially when selection occurs at age 18.

Problems with Community

The lecture identifies two main problems with community: 1. Inclusion/Exclusion: The process of determining who belongs and who doesn't. 2. Conformism: The potential for community to pressure individuals towards conformity, limiting self-expression.

  Takeaways

  • Yale played a pivotal role in the American Revolution, contributing leaders like Roger Sherman and innovations such as David Bushnell’s submarine, while its college operations were repeatedly disrupted by wartime hardships.
  • Timothy Dwight’s 1776 address urged graduates to view themselves as global citizens, promoting American greatness beyond local colonies and using ambiguous language like “conflagration” to inspire broader vision.
  • The lecture links historic collegiate structures to modern concepts of community, showing how imagined communities—from Benedict Anderson’s nations to Yale’s alumni network—create a sense of belonging despite differing membership criteria.
  • Michael Sandel’s critique argues that meritocracy masks the role of luck in elite success, fostering moral arrogance, credentialism, and democratic erosion, especially when college degrees become gatekeepers to respectable work.
  • Two core problems of community identified are inclusion/exclusion—who is allowed in—and conformity pressure, which can suppress individual expression within both academic and broader social groups.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Michael Sandel mean by the "last acceptable prejudice" in his critique of meritocracy?

Sandel uses the phrase to describe credentialism, where a college degree becomes the socially accepted basis for hiring and prestige, effectively discriminating against those without such qualifications. He argues this prejudice legitimizes inequality, undermines democratic participation, and fuels resentment among those excluded from elite opportunities.

How does Benedict Anderson define an imagined community?

Anderson describes a nation as an imagined community that is limited, sovereign, and socially constructed, allowing people who will never meet to feel a deep horizontal comradeship. This framework explains how large groups like nations or alumni networks generate a sense of belonging despite lacking face‑to‑face interaction.

Who is YaleCourses on YouTube?

YaleCourses is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.

Does this page include the full transcript of the video?

Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.

of owing more to members of smaller, closer communities (e.g., family) versus larger ones (e.g., nation). - Effort to improve and represent the community. - Commitment, following rules, participation. - Bringing in new members and respecting older ones (e.g., the Aurelian society). ### Imagined Communities Benedict Anderson's concept of "imagined communities" helps explain the connection people feel to large groups like nations. Anderson, who studied 19th-century nationalist movements, defined

nation as: - Imagined as limited: Even large nations have finite boundaries. - Imagined as sovereign: The concept arose during the Enlightenment and revolutions that challenged divinely-ordained rule. - Imagined as a community: Despite inequalities, a nation is conceived as a "deep horizontal comradeship."

Helpful resources related to this video

If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.

Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.

Full transcript is not shown on this page

This page focuses on the summary and original notes. For full verification, refer to the original YouTube video.

PDF