Metallic Glasses: Structure, Properties, and Deformation
This lecture focuses on metallic glasses, a unique class of amorphous materials not typically covered in standard textbooks. Several research papers on their structural and mechanical behavior are recommended as references.
Historical Development of Metallic Glasses
For a long time, it was believed that metals could not be prepared in an amorphous form due to their rapid crystallization. However, in the 1960s, researchers discovered that thin membranes of metallic glasses could be created, specifically in a binary gold-silicon alloy. This required an extremely fast critical cooling rate of about 1 million degrees Celsius per second. Such rapid cooling rates are only achievable with very small thicknesses, allowing for efficient thermal extraction to prevent crystallization. Early metallic glasses were thus limited to thin film or membrane forms, often prepared using a technique called melt spinning.
Melt spinning involves: 1. A rotating, low-temperature drum. 2. A crucible placed above the drum, from which molten metal flows. 3. The molten metal rapidly cools upon contact with the cold drum. 4. Centrifugal force causes the cooled metal to form a continuous ribbon.
Early Applications and Properties
In the 1970s, metallic glasses found their first commercial applications in magnetic fields, particularly as cores for transformers and generators. Their attractiveness stemmed from two key properties:
- Soft Magnetic Properties: Unlike crystalline metals, amorphous metals lack grain boundaries. This allows magnetic domains to move with much less resistance, resulting in very low magnetic coercivity. They exhibit minimal residual magnetic polarization once an external magnetic field is removed, which is ideal for transformers.
- Higher Electrical Resistivity: Amorphous metals are more electrically resistive than their crystalline counterparts. The lack of long-range order causes more scattering of electronic carriers, leading to reduced mobility and higher resistance. This is beneficial in magnetic applications because it reduces parasitic eddy currents, which dissipate energy and cause power loss in oscillating magnetic fields.
Bulk Metallic Glasses (BMGs) and Commercialization
The 1980s marked a significant breakthrough with the discovery of bulk metallic glasses (BMGs), which possessed much better glass-forming ability. Their critical cooling rates dropped to a few hundred Kelvin per second, enabling the production of macroscopic pieces with millimeter or even centimeter thicknesses.
By the 1990s, more companies entered the field. A notable group at Caltech developed the Vitreloy series of amorphous metals, which gained considerable commercial traction. While still relatively expensive (a small piece could cost $200), Vitreloy was significantly cheaper than earlier amorphous metals that often contained noble metals like gold.
Beyond magnetic applications, BMGs found use in high-end sports gear (skis, golf clubs) and critical components for sensors and automotive applications, where their superior mechanical properties, high-temperature stability, and resistance to degradation and plastic deformation were highly valued.
Metallic Glass Compositions and Evolution
A table illustrating various metallic glass compositions shows their evolution. The horizontal axis represents normalized Gaussian transition temperature, while the vertical axis shows the critical cooling rate (and corresponding maximum thickness). This demonstrates the progression from materials requiring high critical cooling rates (small thickness) to bulk metallic glasses achievable at lower cooling rates (centimeter thickness).
Structural Model of Metallic Glasses
The lecture divides the discussion into two parts: structural models and mechanical behavior.
Chemical Bonding and Packing Density
In metallic glasses, the chemical bonds are primarily metallic, which are non-directional, unlike the covalent bonds in inorganic glasses. The stability of metallic glasses is not primarily determined by network topology (as in inorganic glasses) but by minimizing the Gibbs free energy of the amorphous structure. This is achieved by maximizing packing density, as closer atomic packing leads to stronger interactions between outer shell electrons and atomic nuclei, thereby reducing the system's overall energy.
Inoue's Empirical Rules
Inoue, a pioneer in BMGs, summarized three empirical rules for achieving high glass-forming ability, emphasizing the role of close-packing:
- Multiple Constituent Atoms: At least three or more constituent atoms are required.
- Significant Size Difference: Atoms must have a size difference greater than 15%. This allows for close packing without inducing structural order, preventing crystallization into FCC or HCP structures that would form with similarly sized atoms.
- Negative Enthalpy of Mixing: This ensures thermodynamic stability and prevents segregation of different compositions, meaning the atoms "want" to stay together.
Topological Model for Maximum Packing Density
Similar to Zachariasen's rules for inorganic glasses, Inoue's rules provide an empirical foundation. A more quantitative topological model aims to achieve maximum packing density using different metallic atoms. This model approximates atoms as hard spheres, making it a purely geometric problem. The hypothesis is that the most stable glass composition corresponds to the highest packing density.
2D and 3D Hard Sphere Packing
- 2D Packing (Hard Circles): In a binary system, maximum packing efficiency (unity) is achieved at specific critical radius ratios where one type of circle can perfectly surround the other without gaps. Deviations from these ratios decrease packing efficiency, which then peaks again as the coordination number increases, allowing an extra sphere to fit.
- 3D Packing (Hard Spheres): Similar zigzag patterns of packing efficiency are observed, peaking at critical radius ratios. This suggests that in actual metallic systems, pairs of atoms fulfilling these critical ratios will maximize atomic packing density, leading to the most stable binary metallic glasses.
Experimental Verification
This theory has been experimentally verified, for example, through electron tomography of amorphous metallic nanoparticles. This technique allows for 3D reconstruction of atomic coordinates, confirming the predicted topological local structures.
Extension to Multi-Component BMGs
For ternary, quaternary, and multi-component BMGs, the theory extends to a tiered structure:
- Cluster Formation: Atoms form clusters with a central atom (alpha) surrounded by solute atoms (omega). Maximizing packing density within a cluster requires specific radius ratios and composition ratios, ensuring no gaps.
- Inter-Cluster Packing: Smaller atoms (beta) fill the interstitial sites between these clusters. Crystallography dictates optimal sizes for these interstitial atoms (e.g., octahedral or tetrahedral sites) to maximize overall packing density.
This model assigns topological roles to different atoms: * Alpha: Center atom of a cluster. * Omega: Solvent atoms surrounding the center atom. * Beta/Gamma: Interstitial atoms (beta for octahedral, gamma for tetrahedral sites).
The theory predicts optimal atomic radius ratios and compositions for maximum packing density. Experimental data for multi-component BMGs (e.g., Zirconium-Titanium-Copper-Nickel-Beryllium, Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc-Copper) show remarkable agreement with these topological predictions, even though the model simplifies atoms as hard spheres and neglects chemical interactions. This striking agreement highlights the significant role of topology in glass formation.
Mechanical Properties of Metallic Glasses
Elastic Properties
- Isotropy: Metallic glasses are isotropic due to the absence of grain orientation.
- Lower Elastic Moduli: Their elastic moduli (bulk, shear, Young's) are significantly lower than crystalline metals (e.g., bulk modulus ~6% lower, shear/Young's modulus ~30% smaller). This is attributed to:
- Lower Packing Density: More free volume means atoms are further apart, leading to weaker interatomic interactions and reduced stiffness.
- Lack of Long-Range Order: Reduces the directionality of the structure, contributing to lower bond stiffness.
- Structural Inhomogeneity: Atomic-scale inhomogeneities create softer regions that disproportionately contribute to deformation, lowering the overall elastic modulus.
Plastic Deformation
Unlike crystalline metals where plastic deformation occurs via dislocation motion, amorphous metals lack these defects. This results in a large elastic limit and high yield strength but very poor global plasticity.
- Shear Localization: Plastic deformation in metallic glasses is spatially inhomogeneous. Local regions, being atomically less homogeneous, initiate deformation when stress exceeds the yield point. This process involves the generation and redistribution of free volume. Increased free volume in these regions makes them softer and more prone to further deformation, leading to localization of all plastic deformation into narrow planes called shear bands. This results in catastrophic failure.
Deformation Map
A deformation map illustrates the mechanical behavior of BMGs across temperature (normalized by glass transition temperature, TG) and stress:
- Elastic Regime (Low T, Low Stress): No permanent deformation.
- Inhomogeneous Deformation (Low T, High Stress): Beyond the yield stress, shear localization occurs, leading to abrupt failure. Stress-strain curves show elastic deformation followed by rapid termination.
- Newtonian Fluid Regime (High T ≈ TG, Low Stress): Material becomes viscoelastic. Shear rate is proportional to applied stress. This regime is used for thermoplastic forming, allowing for very large, uniform plastic deformation (e.g., drawing long wires) without breaking, similar to cane drawing in inorganic glasses. Stress-strain curves plateau, indicating constant shear rate.
- Non-Newtonian Fluid Regime (High T ≈ TG, High Stress): Material behaves as a non-Newtonian fluid. Strain rate increases non-linearly with stress. Stress-strain curves show a "bump," indicating a change in viscosity as a function of strain rate, making uniform process control difficult.
Microscopic Mechanisms of Plastic Deformation
Two main microscopic models explain plastic deformation:
- Diffusive Atomic Jump: Smaller-scale deformation where an atom hops between energetically favorable neighboring sites under applied shear stress, leading to directional diffusive flow.
- Shear Transformation Zone (STZ): The more significant mechanism. An STZ is a local atomic arrangement (tens to thousands of atoms) where two clusters of atoms in contact can hop one interatomic spacing relative to each other under shear stress, introducing shear deformation.
- Statistical Nature: Unlike dislocations, STZs are not structural defects and cannot be predicted a priori. Their occurrence is statistical, identified post-deformation.
- Free Volume: Both mechanisms require free volume. Close-packed structures without free volume offer immense resistance to atomic movement. Plastic deformation generates and redistributes free volume.
Shear Localization Explained by STZ Interaction
When an STZ forms, the relative motion of atoms squeezes neighboring atoms, inducing local shear stress. This local stress adds to the macroscopic stress, increasing the probability of new STZs forming in the vicinity of existing ones. This positive feedback loop leads to the rapid formation of shear zones and catastrophic failure. Monte Carlo simulations confirm this strain softening/localization behavior, showing STZs preferentially nucleating near existing ones.
Corrugated Surfaces and Heat Generation
When metallic glass sheets are bent, their surfaces develop corrugated microstructures, with each corrugation corresponding to a shear band. The shear deformation within these bands is enormous, releasing significant energy. Experiments coating metallic glass with low-melting-point tin show that the local temperature within shear zones can exceed tin's melting point, causing the tin film to break into droplets, indicating intense localized heat generation.
Dilatational Process and Pressure Dependence
Plastic deformation in metallic glasses is a dilatational process, meaning it involves volume expansion due to the generation of free volume.
- Compression: Applying compressive stress impedes free volume generation, thus inhibiting plastic deformation and increasing strength.
- Tension: Applying tensile stress facilitates free volume generation, promoting plastic deformation.
This pressure dependence makes shear deformation in metallic glasses analogous to a frictional process. This dilatational behavior is a general phenomenon in amorphous collections of particles, including sand (e.g., dry sand appearing around a foot on a wet beach due to volume expansion squeezing out water).
Fracture Angle Asymmetry
The fracture angle in metallic glasses differs from crystalline metals (which typically fracture at 45 degrees under uniaxial stress due to maximum shear stress).
- Tensile Strain: The fracture angle is greater than 45 degrees. The fracture plane rotates to align more with the tensile stress axis, maximizing tensile stress contribution, which promotes free volume formation and plastic deformation.
- Compressive Strain: The fracture angle is smaller than 45 degrees. The fracture plane rotates to minimize compressive stress contribution, as compression inhibits free volume generation and plastic deformation.
This asymmetric behavior is universally observed in metallic glasses, with tensile tests showing angles greater than 45 degrees and compressive tests showing angles less than 45 degrees.
Strength Asymmetry
Consequently, metallic glasses exhibit different strengths under tension and compression:
- Higher Compressive Strength: Compression inhibits free volume formation and plastic flow, leading to considerably higher strength.
- Lower Tensile Strength: Tension promotes free volume formation and plastic flow, resulting in lower strength.
While inorganic network glasses like silica also show higher compressive strength, their microscopic mechanism is different (crack opening/inhibition vs. free volume generation).
Summary
The lecture concludes by reiterating key points:
- Structural Model: Metallic glasses are stabilized by maximizing the packing density of hard spheres, engineered through atomic radius and fraction, to lower Gibbs free energy from metallic bonds. This is a topological model.
- Mechanical Behavior: The amorphous packing and lack of structural defects lead to:
- Large elastic limits.
- Lower elastic moduli.
- Plastic deformation primarily through Shear Transformation Zones (STZs).
- STZs: These are not structural defects but local atomic transformations that communicate through stress, leading to shear stress localization and catastrophic failure.
Takeaways
- Metallic glasses are amorphous metals whose formation was first achieved in the 1960s by rapidly cooling thin gold‑silicon films at rates around 10⁶ °C s⁻¹, a process known as melt spinning.
- Bulk metallic glasses (BMGs) discovered in the 1980s require much lower critical cooling rates (a few hundred K s⁻¹), enabling centimeter‑scale components and commercial uses such as transformer cores, sports equipment, and automotive parts.
- Inoue’s empirical rules—multiple elements, >15 % atomic size mismatch, and negative enthalpy of mixing—guide the design of high glass‑forming ability alloys by maximizing atomic packing density.
- Plastic deformation in metallic glasses occurs via shear transformation zones (STZs) that generate free volume, leading to shear‑band localization and catastrophic failure, unlike dislocation motion in crystalline metals.
- The mechanical response of BMGs varies with temperature and stress, showing elastic behavior at low T/low stress, shear localization at low T/high stress, and Newtonian or non‑Newtonian fluid regimes near the glass transition, enabling thermoplastic forming.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does a size difference greater than 15% between constituent atoms improve glass‑forming ability?
A size difference greater than 15 % prevents the atoms from arranging into regular crystalline lattices, promoting dense random packing that stabilizes the amorphous structure. The mismatch creates geometric frustration, reduces the tendency for long‑range order, and lowers the critical cooling rate needed to avoid crystallization, which is a key factor in Inoue’s rules for bulk metallic glass formation.
How do shear transformation zones cause shear‑band localization in metallic glasses?
Shear transformation zones (STZs) generate local shear stress that adds to the applied macroscopic stress, increasing the likelihood of nearby STZ formation. This positive feedback creates clusters of STZs that coalesce into narrow shear bands, concentrating deformation and leading to rapid, catastrophic failure because the amorphous matrix lacks dislocation mechanisms to distribute strain.
Who is MIT OpenCourseWare on YouTube?
MIT OpenCourseWare is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.