Viscoelasticity and Structural Relaxation in Glass Transition
This lecture introduces viscoelasticity and relaxation, phenomena that are typically treated separately in glass science textbooks but are combined here due to their shared occurrence during the glass transition regime, similar structural origins (relaxation of glass structure), and identical mathematical formalisms. Both are defining characteristics of the glass transition, a scientifically intriguing area that remains a subject of active investigation, as highlighted by a "Science" journal question: "What is the nature of the glassy state? Where and why does liquid end and glass begin?"
The Defining Feature: Relaxation
Instead of delving into the microstructure of glass transition, the focus is on relaxation as its defining feature. Rheological characteristics of glasses vary with temperature: - Low temperature: Glasses behave as elastic solids, exhibiting instantaneous response and following Hooke's law. - High temperature (supercooled liquid): Glasses behave as viscous liquids, flowing and describable as Newtonian fluids. - Glass transition regime: Exhibits properties combining both solid and liquid characteristics, known as viscoelasticity, and significant structural relaxation occurs here.
A color-coding scheme is used throughout: red for solid/elasticity and blue for liquid/viscous contributions.
Why Relaxation is Significant in the Glass Transition Regime
- Liquid phase: Molecules have high energy, move easily, and access all microscopic states. The system stays in an "equilibrium" state because molecular motion is swift, making relaxation very fast and structural changes almost instantaneous. Liquids are, by definition, always in equilibrium.
- Solid phase (glassy state): Atomic motion is sluggish, kinetically inhibiting relaxation despite a large thermodynamic driving force towards equilibrium. Thus, little structural relaxation is observed.
- Glass transition: This regime provides the right conditions for significant relaxation. Kinetically, it's fast enough to occur within experimental durations, and thermodynamically, there's an adequate driving force as the glass line deviates from the supercooled liquid line.
The significance of relaxation is characterized by comparing the structural relaxation time scale ($\tau_{ie}$) with the observation time ($t_{obs}$). In the glass transition regime, these two time scales are comparable.
Deborah Number
Quantitatively, the Deborah Number ($De$) is defined as the ratio of $\tau$ to $t_{obs}$. Significant structural relaxation (corresponding to the glass transition regime) occurs when $De$ is on the order of unity. The name "Deborah Number" comes from the Bible, referring to the prophetess Deborah observing mountains flowing before the Lord over billions of years, illustrating that with long enough relaxation time, even solids can exhibit viscoelastic response.
Viscoelasticity is a macroscopic manifestation of structural relaxation at the microscopic level. The lecture will focus on the mathematical description of viscoelasticity, which will serve as the basis for deriving the mathematical formalism for structural relaxation.
Mathematical Description of Viscoelasticity
To describe the mechanical properties of viscoelastic solids, a complex shear modulus is used instead of a purely real shear modulus (as in elastic solids). This involves applying a sinusoidally varying shear strain.
- Elastic response: Stress and strain are always in phase, with stress proportional to strain via the elastic constant.
- Viscous response: The constitutive relation (Newtonian flow) shows that stress differs from strain by a factor of $i$ (an imaginary number), meaning their phases differ by $\pi/2$. They are out of phase.
Combining both, the effective shear modulus contains a real part (elastic contribution) and an imaginary part (viscous contribution): - Real part (Storage Modulus): Represents elastic energy stored in the system. - Imaginary part (Loss Modulus): Represents energy dissipated as heat due to internal friction (viscous flow).
Phenomenological Models for Viscoelasticity
To derive the mathematical formalism for relaxation in viscoelastic solids, two basic phenomenological models are introduced:
- Hookean Spring: Represents elastic behavior, where strain is proportional to stress.
- Newtonian Dashpot: Characterizes ideal properties of a Newtonian fluid, where stress is proportional to the strain rate.
These models assume linear relations, applicable when strain and strain rate are very small. Each Newtonian dashpot corresponds to one microscopic structural relaxation mechanism, each with a characteristic relaxation time scale. Different mechanisms (e.g., polymer chain conformation changes vs. bond breaking) can have vastly different time scales, requiring multiple dashpots in a model.
Maxwell Element
This is the simplest assembly: a Hookean spring and a Newtonian dashpot in series. - Stress: Constant across both elements. - Strain: Sum of strains sustained by the spring and dashpot.
Response to External Stimuli:
- Constant Stress: The spring elongates to a fixed amount. The dashpot experiences a constant strain rate, leading to strain growing linearly over time (creep).
- Constant Strain (Stress Relaxation): This is more relevant to relaxation.
- Intuition: Initially, all strain is concentrated on the spring. The stretched spring applies force to the dashpot, which slowly elongates. As the dashpot elongates, the strain on the spring decreases (total strain is constant). The equilibrium state is when the dashpot is fully stretched, and the spring experiences no stress. This is a typical relaxation phenomenon, moving from a non-equilibrium state (stretched spring) to an equilibrium state (no stress).
- Kinetics: The total strain ($\epsilon$) is the sum of elastic ($\epsilon_E$) and viscous ($\epsilon_V$) components.
- $\sigma = G \epsilon_E$ (stress on spring)
- $\sigma = \eta \frac{d\epsilon_V}{dt}$ (stress on dashpot)
- Since $\epsilon = \epsilon_E + \epsilon_V$ and $\epsilon$ is constant, $\frac{d\epsilon_V}{dt} = -\frac{d\epsilon_E}{dt}$.
- This leads to the stress ($\sigma$) decaying exponentially: $\sigma(t) = \sigma_0 e^{-t/\tau}$, where $\tau = \eta/G$ is the relaxation time.
- Driving Force: The internal stress (exerted by the spring) drives the relaxation. The relaxation rate ($d\sigma/dt$) is linearly proportional to the driving force ($\sigma$), with a proportionality constant of $-1/\tau$. This linear scaling of kinetics with driving force is a crucial mathematical formalism that will be applied to structural relaxation in glass materials.
Oscillatory Strain and Loss Tangent:
For oscillatory strain, the loss tangent ($\tan \theta$) is defined as the ratio of the imaginary part of the shear modulus to the real part. It represents the amount of energy lost per cycle, normalized by the stored elastic energy. For a Maxwell element, the loss tangent monotonically decreases with increasing angular frequency ($\omega$), meaning higher frequencies (shorter times) lead to more significant elastic contributions and less energy dissipation per cycle.
Voigt-Kelvin Element
This element places the Hookean spring and Newtonian dashpot in parallel. - Constant Strain: All stress is sustained by the spring (dashpot doesn't respond to constant strain as strain rate is zero). It exhibits stress relaxation. - Constant Stress: Initially, the spring sustains all stress. Over time, the dashpot elongates, and more stress is sustained by the spring. The system exhibits strain relaxation. The kinetics can also be described by an exponential decay.
Generalized Maxwell Model
To describe materials with multiple relaxation mechanisms, a generalized Maxwell model is used, consisting of several Maxwell elements in parallel. Each dashpot corresponds to a unique structural relaxation mechanism. - Stress Relaxation: For constant strain, the internal stress relaxes over time as a sum of many exponential functions (a Prony series), each with its characteristic relaxation time ($\tau_i$). - Stretched Exponential Function: This sum can be expressed as a stretched exponential function: $\sigma(t) = \sigma_0 e^{-(t/\tau)^\beta}$. - If $\beta < 1$, the function initially relaxes faster (due to mechanisms with shorter relaxation times) and then slower (as only mechanisms with longer relaxation times remain), resulting in a longer decay tail compared to a single exponential.
Characteristics of Viscoelastic Response
- Time-dependent: The material's state at any instant depends not only on the instantaneous stress but also on the history of applied stress.
- Boltzmann Superposition Principle: This principle allows predicting the response of a viscoelastic solid to any arbitrary time-varying input stimulus. It relies on the linearity of constitutive relations (Hooke's law, Newtonian flow).
- An arbitrary strain profile can be divided into many small time steps. The total response is the sum of responses from each individual step.
- In the limit of infinitesimally small steps, the sum becomes an integral: $\sigma(t) = G_0 \epsilon(t) + \int_{-\infty}^t \psi(t-t') \frac{d\epsilon(t')}{dt'} dt'$.
- Here, $\psi(t-t')$ is the relaxation function, which describes the kinetics of structural relaxation. If this function is known, the material's response to any stimulus can be derived.
Examples of Viscoelastic Materials
Many amorphous materials operating near their glass transition regime exhibit pronounced viscoelasticity: - Mozzarella cheese: Deforms continuously when hot. - Human skin: Exhibits time-dependent, delayed response (more elastic in babies, more viscous with age). - Turbine blades: At high temperatures, they show creep due to viscoelasticity. - Volcanic lava: A glass-forming fluid, exhibiting viscoelastic response.
Practical Applications:
- Propellers for naval ships: The viscous component helps absorb and dampen vibrations, reducing noise for stealth.
- Memory foam: A classic everyday example of a viscoelastic material.
Structural Relaxation in Glasses
The mathematical formalism for structural relaxation in glasses is derived by drawing an analogy with stress relaxation in a Maxwell element.
To analyze relaxation kinetics, three factors are considered:
Equilibrium State:
- Maxwell element: When stress completely drops to zero (dashpot fully stretched, spring not elongated).
- Glass structure: The supercooled liquid state is considered the "equilibrium" state towards which glass relaxes, even though it's not thermodynamically stable below the melting point.
Driving Force:
- Maxwell element: Residual stress inside the material (exerted by the Hookean spring).
- Glass structure: The deviation of the current state from the equilibrium state. For volume relaxation, this is the difference between the current volume ($V$) and the equilibrium volume ($V_e$) of the supercooled liquid at the same temperature. This difference, $V - V_e$, is also known as the free volume ($V_f$), representing the excess volume the glass possesses. The system tries to minimize $V_f$.
Relaxation Kinetics:
- Maxwell element: Relaxation rate is linearly proportional to the driving force: $d\sigma/dt = -(1/\tau)\sigma$.
- Glass structure: The same assumption is made: the relaxation rate scales linearly with the driving force. For volume relaxation at a fixed temperature, $dV/dt = dV_f/dt = -(1/\tau_{relax})V_f$. Here, $\tau_{relax}$ is the characteristic relaxation time scale in the glass.
Temperature Dependence of Relaxation Time
Since structural relaxation involves atomic/molecular motion, its kinetics can be described by an Arrhenius equation as a first-order approximation: $\tau_{relax}(T) = \tau_0 e^{E_a/k_B T}$. This equation is crucial for correlating the relaxation rate with temperature during thermal processing.
Predicting Glass Response During Thermal Processing
To predict how glass volume evolves over time during a process (e.g., cooling and reheating), a finite difference approach can be used: 1. Initial State: Know the starting volume at $t_1$. 2. Temperature History: Know how temperature changes over time, $T(t)$. 3. Iterative Calculation: For a small time step $dt$: - Calculate $dV/dt$ using the relaxation kinetics equation: $dV/dt = -(1/\tau_{relax}(T))(V - V_e(T))$. - All quantities on the right side are known: $\tau_{relax}(T)$ from the Arrhenius equation (knowing $T$), $V$ from the previous step, and $V_e(T)$ from the supercooled liquid line (knowing $T$). - Update the volume: $V(t+dt) = V(t) + (dV/dt)dt$. - Repeat for subsequent time steps.
This remarkably simple yet powerful method allows predicting glass behavior during thermal processing.
Examples of Predictions:
Same Cooling Rate, Different Reheating Rates:
- Starting from a supercooled liquid, cooling at a constant rate (e.g., 10°C/s) follows the supercooled liquid line, then deviates into the glassy state.
- During reheating, the glass, initially far from equilibrium with large excess free volume, tries to relax.
- The volume curve bends downwards, indicating relaxation towards the supercooled liquid line.
- Slower reheating rates allow more time for relaxation, causing the curve to dip more significantly.
- Eventually, as temperature rises, relaxation kinetics accelerate, allowing the system to fully remain in equilibrium and trace the supercooled liquid line.
Different Cooling Rates, Constant Reheating Rate:
- During cooling, the system initially traces the supercooled liquid line.
- Faster cooling rates cause the system to deviate from the supercooled liquid line earlier because relaxation kinetics are not fast enough to keep up. This results in a higher volume (more excess free volume) for faster-cooled glasses.
- During reheating, faster-cooled glasses (with higher excess free volume) exhibit stronger structural relaxation (a more significant dip in the volume curve) due to a larger driving force.
- This theory can be used to derive the dependence of fictive temperature on cooling rate.
- Note: The schematic typically shows a finite slope for the glass line (due to thermal expansion), which can be easily added to the model.
This lecture concludes by emphasizing the importance of understanding how to mathematically model structural relaxation using first-order kinetic theory. The next lecture will delve into fictive temperature and Tool's equations.
Takeaways
- Relaxation, not microstructure, is highlighted as the defining feature of the glass transition, with viscoelastic behavior emerging when elastic and viscous contributions coexist.
- The Deborah Number, the ratio of structural relaxation time to observation time, indicates significant relaxation when it is around unity, linking macroscopic viscoelastic response to microscopic dynamics.
- Phenomenological models such as the Maxwell and Voigt‑Kelvin elements use springs and dashpots to derive exponential stress or strain relaxation, and the generalized Maxwell model combines many elements to produce stretched‑exponential behavior.
- Structural relaxation in glasses can be modeled analogously to stress relaxation, with the free‑volume difference acting as the driving force and a first‑order kinetic equation (dV/dt = –V_f/τ) governing volume change.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Deborah Number and why is it important for the glass transition?
The Deborah Number (De) is the ratio of a material’s structural relaxation time (τ) to the observation time (t_obs); when De ≈ 1, relaxation occurs on the experimental timescale, marking the glass‑transition regime. It quantifies when a solid begins to exhibit viscoelastic flow, linking microscopic dynamics to macroscopic behavior.
How does the Maxwell element model stress relaxation in viscoelastic materials?
In a Maxwell element, a spring (elastic) and dashpot (viscous) are connected in series, so constant strain forces the spring to store stress while the dashpot gradually elongates, causing the stress to decay exponentially as σ(t)=σ₀e^{‑t/τ}. This exponential decay captures the essential kinetics of stress relaxation in viscoelastic solids.
Who is MIT OpenCourseWare on YouTube?
MIT OpenCourseWare is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
"What is the nature of the glassy state? Where and why does liquid end and glass begin?" ## The Defining Feature: Relaxation Instead of delving into the microstructure of glass transition, the focus is on relaxation as its defining feature. Rheological characteristics of glasses vary with temperature: - **Low temperature:** Glasses behave as elastic solids, exhibiting instantaneous response and following Hooke's law. - **High temperature (supercooled liquid):** Glasses behave as viscous liquids, flowing and describable as Newtonian fluids. - **Glass transition regime:** Exhibits properties combining both solid and liquid characteristics, known as viscoelasticity, and significant structural relaxation occurs here.
color-coding scheme is used throughout: red for solid/elasticity and blue for liquid/viscous contributions.
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.