Relational Reality: How Perception Shapes What Is Real

•

 7 min video

•

 3 min read

YouTube video ID: 8RUjEGFFLTc

Source: YouTube video by Big Think — Watch original video

PDF

Humans have long debated the nature of reality. Traditionally, reality was considered objective, existing separately from us, and our perception of it was either accurate or inaccurate. However, this view is incomplete. Reality is not purely objective, nor is it purely subjective; it is relational.

Relational Reality

Lisa Feldman Barrett, a distinguished professor of psychology at Northeastern University, explains that there is one reality, but it is perspective-dependent. For example, if a person expresses anger to a therapist, and the therapist perceives sadness, both experiences contribute to the reality of the situation. This means reality exists in relation to the observer.

Every experience is a combination of the remembered past and the sensory present. The brain uses past experiences to anticipate sensory signals from the world. This suggests that reality is not entirely external to us, nor is it solely internal; it is a combination of both.

The Perception Box

The "perception box" refers to the remembered past and the relationship between what is inside our heads and what is outside in the world. Relational realism suggests that our perception box contains the ingredients and signals we use to create our relational present.

The Falling Tree Parable

The classic parable asks: "If a tree falls in the forest and nobody is there to hear it, does it make a sound?" A relational realist would argue that a falling tree causes vibrations in the air, but for it to be a "sound," there must be receptors to detect those vibrations and an organism to interpret them as the sound of a tree falling. If no organism is present to detect and interpret the signals, then, from a relational perspective, the tree does not make a sound.

Different Realities for Different Organisms

Animals possess sensory surfaces that humans do not, leading to different realities for them. For instance, whales detect vibration-based noise in the ocean that is irrelevant to humans. These signals, due to the whales' sensory surfaces and brains, are part of their reality. Human ignorance of these different perspectives can interfere with animal communication.

Implications for Human Interaction

This concept extends to human interactions. In arguments, people often appeal to the authority of objective reality to assert their correctness. However, if reality is relational, this approach is flawed. Resolving conflict requires acknowledging that another person's experience holds equivalent authority to one's own.

Recognizing that someone else's experience is part of reality does not invalidate one's own experience. It simply means that one's experience is a part of reality, but not the only part. There are shared aspects of reality, and there are aspects unique to each individual.

Expanding Your Reality

Spending time with people who share similar reactions and experiences reinforces a limited, easily conjured remembered past. To expand one's understanding of reality, it is crucial to be curious and seek new signals and meanings. This involves being humble and open to experiencing as many aspects of reality as possible. Ignorance, in this context, is not helpful. The goal is not objectivity, but rather the ability to experience the broadest possible spectrum of reality.

  Takeaways

  • Reality is neither purely objective nor purely subjective; it exists relationally, depending on the observer’s perspective and past experiences.
  • The brain combines remembered past with current sensory input, creating a “perception box” that shapes each individual’s present reality.
  • A relational realist would say a falling tree only makes a sound when an organism detects and interprets the vibrations, highlighting that sound depends on a perceiver.
  • Different species experience distinct realities because their sensory systems detect signals humans cannot, so human ignorance can hinder inter‑species communication.
  • Expanding one’s reality requires curiosity, humility, and exposure to new signals and perspectives, rather than striving for an impossible objective truth.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does the "perception box" refer to in relational realism?

The "perception box" is the mental construct that combines an individual’s stored memories with incoming sensory data, linking what is inside the brain to what is outside in the world. It supplies the ingredients and signals the brain uses to generate the relational present.

Why does a relational realist claim a falling tree doesn't make a sound without a listener?

A relational realist argues that a falling tree only produces a sound when an organism’s receptors detect the air vibrations and the brain interprets them as sound; without a perceiver, the vibrations exist but the phenomenon of “sound” does not arise.

Who is Big Think on YouTube?

Big Think is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.

Does this page include the full transcript of the video?

Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.

Helpful resources related to this video

If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.

Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.

Full transcript is not shown on this page

This page focuses on the summary and original notes. For full verification, refer to the original YouTube video.

PDF