Distinguishing a Solid Self and a Pseudo Self
Luke Burgess, founder and director of the Clooney Institute and author of "Wanting: The Power of Mimetic Desire in Everyday Life" and "The 99: Forging Identity in the Age of Social Contagion," discusses the two levels of the self, the three temptations of the screen, and the four forms of courage essential for modern life.
Distinguishing a Solid Self and a Pseudo Self
In an age of social contagion, finding tribes is easier than ever, especially with the internet. The critical question is how to exist within a tribe healthily without losing oneself. We are constantly immersed in tribes, often picking and choosing them daily for validation. The harder skill is not merely leaving a tribe, but being part of any strong community without dissolving one's identity.
Humans have a fundamental drive for communion and a desire to be recognized for their uniqueness. These two drives exist in a healthy tension. When this tension is avoided, individuals and society often fall into either individualism or collectivism. Healthy community emerges when a person can sit in this tension, which is a sign of life.
The process of belonging to a community in a healthy way is called differentiation. This doesn't mean leaving or becoming alienated, but rather maintaining one's distinctiveness while remaining in communion. This leads to healthier communities and groups. A concern today is the loss of this ability, as people flee tension and the rites of passage that facilitate differentiation. Rites of passage involve three stages: separation, a liminal phase where identity is in flux, and reintegration into relationships in a new, more mature way. Holding the tension between individuality and belonging is the work of adult maturation.
According to Joe Forgus, a leading researcher on tribes, defining characteristics of tribal membership include: - In-group loyalty: Favoring members of one's own group. - Shared narrative: A common story or belief system accepted by all members. - Expectation of conformity: Certain behaviors or beliefs are required to be part of the tribe.
These characteristics can become unhealthy when taken to extremes, leading to what is commonly understood as negative tribalism. A simple test for healthy tribalism is whether the tribe helps individuals mature and grow, or if they must dissolve themselves into the group, losing their own will.
Research by Henri Tajfeld in the 1970s demonstrated how easily humans form tribal associations. In a study, students were randomly labeled "overestimators" or "underestimators" after a meaningless task. Despite the arbitrary nature of the labels, students immediately began to reward their own group, even if it meant harming their own ability to maximize personal gain, as long as it increased the distance between them and the other side. This highlights an ingrained human tendency to behave tribally, even against self-interest, especially when labels are assigned. The internet and algorithms exacerbate this by grouping individuals without their explicit consent, often leading to a comfortable acceptance of these labels without experiencing the healthy tension necessary for differentiation.
Murray Bowen's Family Systems Theory
Murray Bowen, a family psychiatrist in the 1950s and 60s, made a breakthrough by applying systems theory to the family unit. He argued that an individual's problems could not be understood in isolation but only within the context of their entire family emotional system, extending back to grandparents and siblings. He viewed the family as an "undifferentiated ego mass," where members often fuse and share emotions, losing their individual emotional distinctiveness.
Bowen focused on how individuals differentiate themselves within their family, learning where their emotions end and another's begin. This basic level of differentiation is then carried into the wider world—work, politics, and other social contexts. He believed that much of the world's anxiety and conflict stems from unresolved differentiation in people's families. Anxiety within a family spreads like electricity, often absorbed by the person least differentiated.
The family is the first community we are part of, where we are initially undifferentiated from our mothers. It's the primary place where we learn differentiation, a process influenced by how differences are rewarded or punished. We often don't recognize the invisible web of relationships and emotional energy within a family, tending to blame individuals rather than the system. Bowen advocated for stepping back and objectively viewing the family as a unit, as emotional reactivity often clouds judgment within close relationships.
The Pseudo Self vs. The Solid Self
Bowen coined the term pseudo self to describe the level of self that is negotiable in real-time. It's an adaptable, chameleon-like version of oneself that adopts the ideas, emotions, and energy of a group to find commonality and rapport with the least amount of tension. This constant renegotiation is exhausting and prevents the development of a real, stable self.
In contrast, the solid self is intentionally formed through reflection and conscious thought about one's beliefs, thoughts, and feelings. It's the ability to use "I" statements, taking responsibility for one's own convictions, rather than constantly defaulting to "we" statements. Unhealthy communities often speak only in "we" statements, where individual responsibility is diluted. A solid self can stand on its own feet, even in a room full of differing opinions, without feeling its identity slip away. Consistently yielding one's moral convictions to avoid tension leads to a highly undifferentiated pseudo self.
Differentiation is the process of distinguishing one's emotions, thoughts, feelings, and beliefs from those closest to them or from the crowd. It prevents fusion and loss of self. However, true differentiation is difficult. An easy, but unhealthy, way to differentiate is through "emotional cutoff," completely severing relationships. Bowen emphasized that differentiation means being in relationship as a differentiated self, maintaining distinctiveness while remaining connected.
A practical exercise for differentiation is writing a "belief paper," reflecting deeply on the origins of one's strongly held beliefs. Often, beliefs are formed through social processes and influences, and it's crucial to investigate how much of a belief is driven by a desire for approval. Gossip, for example, presents a common opportunity for differentiation: choosing not to participate or taking a different stance from the group's consensus. The undifferentiated path is to quickly resolve the tension created by disagreement, while the differentiated path is to own one's stance and sit with the discomfort. This builds a confident self capable of being in a tribe without losing oneself.
The Example of August Landmesser
August Landmesser, who joined the Nazi party for job opportunities in the early 1930s, later fell in love with a Jewish woman. He initially believed he could maintain distance from the party's ideology, but faced severe consequences for his relationship, including threats of jail and eventual death in a penal battalion. A famous photograph from a 1936 rally in Hamburg shows Landmesser standing with his arms crossed, defiantly refusing to give the Nazi salute amidst a sea of saluting men.
This act exemplifies a solid self. Landmesser, having suffered trials due to his relationship, realized the true nature of the party and began to differentiate himself. His action was not for performance or social media praise; he had no idea the photograph was being taken. He was able to say, "I will not take this particular action, even if it costs me my life." This conviction, born from his response to the objective goodness of his relationship and the duties he owed his fiancée, transcended the socially mediated values of the group.
The Power of Crowds and the Hive Conscience
Gustav Le Bon's 1895 book, "The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind," recognized the crowd as the most important social technology of the industrial revolution. He studied how individuals lose themselves in the "collective effervescence" of a crowd, their will subsumed by the group's will, leading them to act in ways they never would alone. René Girard observed that rituals like stoning were often performed by crowds, not individuals, to absolve personal responsibility. The anonymity within a crowd makes it attractive to pseudo selves, allowing them to give themselves over to the "we" without owning responsibility.
Often, judgments are formed only after absorbing the opinions of others, mediated by news and social media. This "hive conscience" prioritizes how a judgment aligns one with a group, rather than an objective evaluation of reality. The solid self, however, can have immediate contact with reality, stripping away mediation to form independent judgments.
Things can be important for two reasons: 1. Socially mediated importance: Valued because others value it, regardless of objective worth (e.g., social media trends). 2. Intrinsic importance: Valued for its inherent goodness, making a claim on us even if no one else cares (e.g., Landmesser's love for his fiancée).
The danger of crowds and tribes is that values are often mediated solely within the group, lacking anything that transcends it. Landmesser's act was transcendent, responding to an objective goodness beyond the immediate social context.
Being part of groups can lead to comfort and validation, but also stagnation. If individuals in a group only make decisions as a whole, without independent thought, it becomes an undifferentiated mass. The goal is not to leave or join a tribe, but to achieve "communion after differentiation"—to be part of groups strong enough to tolerate and encourage differentiated, evolving individuals. The weakest, most insecure groups cannot tolerate a differentiated self.
The Three Temptations of the Screen
Jack Dorsey suggested that the debate around free speech distracts from the more critical issue of free will. Modern technologies program us, shaping our will through discovery mechanisms and algorithms. Free speech is the outward expression of free will, so understanding how the will is formed and shaped by crowds and technology is crucial for speaking as oneself, not merely as a member of a crowd.
Social contagion, accelerated by technology, is a powerful phenomenon where emotions, ideas, and identity spread quickly and unconsciously. It was difficult to be a differentiated self in a family without smartphones; it is exponentially harder today, bombarded by expectations from thousands of people, making it difficult to know where one ends and others begin. We act instinctively and reflexively to fit in, often without reflection, losing the "I" in interaction.
Robin Dunbar's number, 150, represents the maximum number of stable relationships a human can maintain. Beyond this, relationships become superficial, often operating at the level of the pseudo self. Dunbar emphasized the importance of micro-communities (7-8 intimate relationships) for forming a solid self. Today, constant immersion in large online networks prevents many from developing solid relationships in smaller numbers, forcing them to operate primarily as pseudo selves.
The screen presents three powerful temptations that hinder the formation of a solid self:
- Thinner Rites of Passage: Traditional rites of passage, which involve difficult, risky, and often solitary experiences, are crucial for differentiation and character formation. These have largely migrated online, becoming substitutes that offer less friction and depth, failing to truly form or mature individuals.
- Curiositas (Disordered Desire for Knowledge): Augustine of Hippo described curiositas as a passionate, disordered desire for knowledge, akin to lust for the body, where knowing itself is the goal, regardless of its benefit. The internet amplifies this, presenting a constant stream of "car wrecks" (sensational news, random facts) to gawk at. This dissipates the kind of knowledge that truly matters (studiositas), which is directed towards a specific good (e.g., a cure for Alzheimer's). Curiositas is a possessive desire for knowledge without a common good or end.
- Acedia (Spiritual Restlessness): Named by desert monks in the 4th and 5th centuries, acedia is often mistranslated as sloth. It's an extreme restlessness of mind and soul, an inability to adhere to present reality or responsibilities, a desire to be anywhere else. Modern technology amplifies this, leading to constant scrolling, sleepless nights, and an inability to experience true leisure. This spiritual restlessness, distinct from mere dopamine hits, makes nothing ever enough, driving a constant search for "something more." Acedia fuels curiositas, which in turn leads to thin, counterfeit rites of passage, preventing the development of solid selves.
Marshall McLuhan noted that technology extends one human sense while often diminishing others. Thomas Aquinas's concept of sensus communis (not common sense, but the convergence of all sensory faculties—physical, intellectual, and spiritual—to perceive reality as it is) is relevant here. Jacques Lusseyran, a blind French Resistance member, developed an intuitive sensus communis, perceiving people as "hues and sources of light" and sensing their trustworthiness. This suggests a deeper, unified way of perceiving reality. Technology, however, scrambles our senses, preventing this holistic perception.
Our level of differentiation can be functional, varying by context. We might be a solid self at work but a pseudo self with old friends or family. While a baseline differentiation comes from family, the modern world's numerous contexts and constant "context switching" (changing jobs, online communities) make it incredibly difficult for those without a solid self. The solid self allows one to be the same person in any context. The danger is an "adaptation trap," where the skill of rapid adaptation leads to the pseudo self, rewarded for conformity and punished for non-adaptation. The key to developing a solid self is learning to sit in the tension between one's integrity and group affiliations, without completely yielding.
The problem today is not discomfort, but too much comfort in groups and systems, leading to a sleepwalking existence without intentionality. We need to "defamiliarize" our world, making the familiar strange again to see it objectively. This process is personal and requires effort.
The term "demonic" can describe the forces and effects of technology. Not necessarily in a religious sense, but as something external that affects or takes over our will, eroding agency subtly. Jack Dorsey's concern about the loss of free will aligns with this. The biblical story of "Legion" (many demons possessing one man) illustrates how the "many" can affect the "one" to the point of losing individual agency. The demonic operates invisibly, subtly eroding will until we believe we are making our own decisions when we are not.
The Importance of Courage
Courage is paramount in the modern world, not just in heroic acts but in daily life. It can be understood in four forms:
- The Courage to Be: This is the foundational, existential courage to affirm existence and its goodness daily, even in the face of meaninglessness (Paul Tillich's concept). It means not sleepwalking through life, being present, and affirming the goodness of others. This is the antidote to acedia, the restlessness that avoids present reality.
- The Courage to Be Apart: This is the courage to overcome individualistic, selfish tendencies and be part of something bigger than oneself—a team, a community. It means leaning in, letting go of isolation, and engaging with others, even when it's difficult.
- The Courage to Be Oneself: This is the courage to show up with integrity, as a solid self, without sacrificing one's beliefs or authenticity. This creates tension, which most people flee, but embracing this tension is crucial for developing a solid self.
- The Courage to Be in Communion: This form encompasses the previous three. Communion is a deeper bond than mere community, where differentiated individuals have the courage to be together without dissolving into one another. It's a healthy state where differentiation is allowed and encouraged. It honors both the drive to be known as oneself and the desire to be with others, without sacrificing integrity.
We are often conditioned to believe that tension or discomfort is bad, signaling something is wrong. However, tension is often a sign of life, indicating that one is not sacrificing integrity for temporary peace. The best relationships are those that become stronger by working through differences, which requires courage to not flee tension. Technology often engineers away friction, including in relationships, but embracing friction is essential for developing a solid self. The word "courage" comes from the Latin "core" (heart), implying an acknowledgment of feelings, including discomfort, and an invitation to lean into them, have difficult conversations, and undertake necessary rites of passage.
Alexei Navalny, the Russian dissident, exemplifies these four forms of courage. Despite being poisoned and facing certain death, he chose to return to Russia, demonstrating: - The Courage to Be: Affirming existence in the face of death. - The Courage to Be Apart: Returning to his country and people. - The Courage to Be Oneself: Not sacrificing his beliefs or authenticity, even under immense pressure. - The Courage to Be in Communion: Fighting for the freedom and common good of others, even when many did not understand or support him. He addressed those around him as pseudo selves who had negotiated a false peace, highlighting the danger of sacrificing integrity for temporary comfort.
The most rewarding and healthy path involves seeking out situations that allow for differentiation and communion, rather than easy solutions that require no courage.
Takeaways
- Bowen's concept of the pseudo self describes a chameleon‑like, adaptable self that constantly adopts group ideas to avoid tension, which exhausts personal development.
- The solid self is built through conscious reflection and the ability to use "I" statements, allowing individuals to maintain distinct identity while remaining in a tribe.
- Modern technology creates three screen temptations—thin rites of passage, curiositas, and acedia—that undermine the formation of a solid self by offering shallow experiences, endless disordered knowledge, and restless distraction.
- Courage manifests in four forms—being, being apart, being oneself, and being in communion—and each is essential for sustaining differentiation within communities.
- Healthy tribalism supports differentiation, whereas extreme loyalty and conformity dissolve individuality, as illustrated by August Landmesser’s defiant refusal to salute despite lethal risk.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a solid self and a pseudo self?
A solid self is an intentionally formed identity created through reflection and personal responsibility, while a pseudo self is a flexible, chameleon‑like persona that constantly adopts group ideas to avoid tension. This ongoing negotiation drains energy and blocks the development of authentic convictions.
How do the three temptations of the screen prevent the formation of a solid self?
The three screen temptations—thin rites of passage, curiositas, and acedia—undermine solid self formation by replacing deep, challenging experiences with shallow, endless stimulation. Thin rites provide low‑friction rituals that fail to build character, curiositas fuels a compulsive hunger for random facts without purpose, and acedia creates restless scrolling that prevents sustained focus, all of which keep individuals in a pseudo self state.
Who is Big Think on YouTube?
Big Think is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
is how to exist within
tribe healthily without losing oneself. We are constantly immersed in tribes, often picking and choosing them daily for validation. The harder skill is not merely leaving a tribe, but being part of any strong community without dissolving one's identity.
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.