Relational Realism: How Social Consensus Shapes Perceived Reality

•

 6 min video

•

 3 min read

YouTube video ID: KLeOL1CFZVM

Source: YouTube video by Big Think — Watch original video

PDF

Many aspects of reality that we often perceive as objective are, in fact, rooted in social reality and cultural inheritance. This concept, known as relational realism, suggests that our understanding of the world is shaped by the relationship between external physical signals and the internal interpretations we impose on them.

The Nature of Social Reality

Social reality refers to features where a group of people collectively impose a meaning on physical signals that those signals do not inherently possess. Examples include:

  • Color: What constitutes "red" is not an intrinsic property of a wavelength of light. Instead, it's a learned interpretation based on how our brains process light hitting the retina and how others have taught us to categorize those signals.
  • Mountains vs. Hills: The distinction between a mountain and a hill is a socially agreed-upon classification, not an objective physical difference.
  • Presidency: The definition of a president and their powers are established through collective agreement and societal structures.

These meanings are not inherent; they are learned through cultural inheritance.

Cultural Inheritance and the Perception Box

Cultural inheritance is the process by which individuals learn to impose meaning on physical signals that lack intrinsic meaning. It's how other people, through their actions and words, "wire" our brains with a remembered past. This remembered past forms our "perception box," which we then use to interpret and create the relational present.

This knowledge transfer from one generation to another is fundamental to how we perceive and interact with reality. All aspects we might consider objective features of reality are, in this view, culturally inherited.

Consensus and the Manifestation of Reality

The imposition of meaning on physical signals requires a consensus, or an implied consensus, among people. For instance, the existence of a color like burgundy depends on prior instances where individuals were taught the patterns that allowed them to use their "perception box" for color. This enables them to not just experience, but to create and act on wavelengths of light as "burgundy."

In essence, external signals are given meaning by their relation to internal signals within our heads, through collective agreement. This means even something as seemingly fundamental as the existence of color is a form of social reality.

Money as a Classic Example

Money is a prime example of social reality. When we exchange pieces of paper for goods or services, we are not just agreeing to the existence of money; we are actively manifesting its existence. The more people who agree to its value, the more solidified that value becomes.

The fragility of social reality is evident when consensus breaks down. If a group of people withdraw their consent that pieces of paper can be traded for material goods, money ceases to exist in that context. The 2008 mortgage crisis illustrates this: when a group of individuals withdrew their consent regarding the value of mortgages, it plunged the world into an economic crisis.

The Flexibility and Constraints of Reality

While reality is perspective-dependent and flexible, it is not infinitely so. We cannot simply achieve consensus on any idea and have it become true. For example, a group of people could agree that ground glass is food, but this would not make it true. There are biological constraints on what counts as food, and the patterns that emerge from including these biological signals also matter significantly.

Therefore, reality is shaped by the interplay of signals both "out there" (physical world) and "in here" (our brains and collective interpretations).

Our Role in Shaping Reality

Our daily actions, choices, and decisions contribute to the creation of reality. Whether we vote or not, follow a social influencer or not, or choose to eat one thing over another, these actions manifest the reality we then have to navigate. This implies that individuals possess significant power in determining which signal patterns are recognized as reality and which are not.

  Takeaways

  • Relational realism argues that what we consider objective reality is actually constructed through the relationship between external physical signals and the internal meanings we collectively assign.
  • Social reality emerges when groups impose shared interpretations on neutral physical signals, such as color categories, the distinction between mountains and hills, or the definition of a presidency.
  • Cultural inheritance transmits these interpretations across generations, forming a “perception box” that shapes how individuals experience and create the relational present.
  • Money exemplifies social reality: its value exists only because enough people consent to it, and the 2008 mortgage crisis showed how withdrawing that consensus can collapse the system.
  • While reality is flexible, biological and physical constraints limit what consensus can turn into truth, meaning not every agreed‑upon idea—like treating glass as food—becomes real.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does relational realism claim that color is not an intrinsic property of light?

Relational realism holds that color arises from the brain’s interpretation of wavelengths combined with socially learned categories, not from the light itself; the wavelength is a physical signal, but “red” or “burgundy” only exist because people collectively assign those labels based on cultural conventions.

How does the 2008 mortgage crisis demonstrate the dependence of money’s value on collective consent?

The crisis showed that when lenders, investors, and borrowers stopped trusting mortgage-backed securities, the shared agreement that those papers represented real value collapsed, causing money tied to them to lose purchasing power; this loss of consensus triggered a systemic breakdown, proving that money’s existence relies on collective belief.

Who is Big Think on YouTube?

Big Think is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.

Does this page include the full transcript of the video?

Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.

Helpful resources related to this video

If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.

Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.

Full transcript is not shown on this page

This page focuses on the summary and original notes. For full verification, refer to the original YouTube video.

PDF