Glass vs Sapphire: Strength, Cost, and Latest Toughening Technologies
The lecture begins by revisiting chemically strengthened glass, like Gorilla Glass, which utilizes an ion exchange process to create a large surface compressive stress, preventing crack propagation. This process yields two key improvements:
Improvements from Ion Exchange Process
- Higher Strength: The Weibull plot for chemically strengthened glass shifts to the right, indicating it can withstand higher stress before fracturing.
- Increased Consistency: The slope of the Weibull plot increases, signifying a higher Weibull modulus. This means the glass has a narrower distribution of defects, leading to a more reproducible and consistent product finish compared to untreated soda-lime glass, which has a wider distribution of defect sizes and severities.
These strengthened glasses are now standard cover materials for most consumer electronic products.
Glass vs. Sapphire: A Comparison
The discussion then shifts to alternative materials, particularly sapphire, which was once considered a potential replacement for glass in iPhone screens. Apple invested significantly in GT Advanced Materials to ramp up sapphire screen manufacturing, but the venture ultimately failed, leading to the company's bankruptcy. However, Apple still uses sapphire in some high-end products, notably certain Apple Watch models.
A comparison of key properties between strengthened glass and sapphire reveals why Apple makes specific material choices:
Optical Properties
- Refractive Index: Sapphire has a slightly higher refractive index (around 1.76) compared to glass (around 1.5), leading to more reflection (7.5-8% for sapphire vs. 4% for glass). While anti-reflection coatings can mitigate this, glass inherently has lower surface reflectance.
Density
- Density: Sapphire is denser than glass. For larger devices like iPads, this added weight can be significant, but for smaller devices like the Apple Watch, the difference is negligible.
Fracture Toughness
- Fracture Toughness: Sapphire boasts a fracture toughness 2 to 3 times higher than typical glass materials. This led to claims of sapphire being "3 times stronger." However, this comparison is not entirely fair because the reported fracture toughness of glass often doesn't account for the additional resistance to crack propagation provided by the surface compressive stress from ion strengthening.
Flexural Strength
- Flexural Strength: This measures a material's ability to resist bending before breaking. Sapphire and strengthened glass have comparable flexural strengths, meaning their performance in resisting deformation is similar in this regard.
Young's Modulus (Stiffness)
- Young's Modulus: Sapphire is significantly stiffer, with a Young's modulus about 5 times higher than typical glasses (around 400 GPa for sapphire vs. 60-75 GPa for glass). This is a crucial factor when the screen is integrated into a device.
- If the screen is the stiffest component (e.g., sapphire on an aluminum casing with a Young's modulus of ~70 GPa), most of the stress from an impact will be concentrated on the screen, increasing its risk of failure.
- However, if the casing material also has a high Young's modulus, like stainless steel (>200 GPa), the modulus mismatch is smaller. This explains why Apple uses sapphire screens on stainless steel or titanium Apple Watch models, as the stress distribution is more balanced. Other premium manufacturers like Samsung make similar choices for their high-end watches.
Hardness (Scratch Resistance)
- Hardness: Sapphire excels in hardness, being one of the hardest materials (second only to diamond). This translates to superior scratch resistance. Surface scratches are common defects that can lead to catastrophic failure in screens. Sapphire significantly reduces the risk of scratches from everyday items like keys.
Cost and Perception
- Cost: Sapphire is more expensive than glass. Its cost has decreased due to the LED industry's demand for sapphire substrates (for blue LEDs), but it remains pricier. This contributes to its use in high-end products.
- Perception: Sapphire is perceived as a "luxury" material or gemstone, adding to its appeal in premium devices, whereas glass is not.
Advances in Glass Technology
Despite sapphire's advantages, glass technology continues to evolve, with new innovations enhancing its properties.
Scratch-Resistant Glasses (e.g., Corning Gorilla Glass SR+, DX+)
Corning has developed scratch-resistant glasses like SR+ and DX+. While the exact mechanisms are proprietary, analysis of their transmission spectra suggests the presence of a surface coating. This coating, likely with higher hardness, prevents scratches. The observed fringes in the transmission spectrum indicate interference patterns, consistent with a thin film (estimated 2.3 microns thick) with a refractive index slightly different from the substrate glass.
Native Damage Resistance (NDR) Glass
This ingenious approach engineers the intrinsic properties of glass to resist damage. When scratched, NDR glass exhibits significant plastic deformation (densification) rather than forming microcracks. This is achieved by incorporating boron into the glass network. Boron exhibits an "anomaly," switching between three-fold (B3) and four-fold (B4) coordination. In NDR glass, applied stress induces a transformation from B3 to B4, increasing network connectivity and density. This stress-induced chemical transformation absorbs deformation, inhibiting crack formation.
Bendable Phone Screens (e.g., Samsung Galaxy Z Flip)
Modern ultra-thin glasses can be made flexible and foldable. The key is extreme thinness (25-30 microns, about 1/3 the thickness of paper) combined with chemical strengthening to induce high surface compressive stress.
- Physics of Bending: When a glass sheet is bent, the top surface experiences tensile strain, and the bottom experiences compressive strain. The strain (ε) on the top surface is given by ε = (1/2)
- (thickness / bending radius).
- Strain and Stress Calculation: For a 30-micron thick glass bent to a 1mm radius, the surface strain is 1.5%. With a Young's modulus of 60 GPa, this translates to a tensile stress of 900 MPa.
- Role of Chemical Strengthening: Since chemically strengthened glass can have compressive stresses of 900 MPa or more, even under extreme bending, the surface remains in a tensile stress-free or even compressive state, preventing crack initiation.
- Samsung Z Flip: The Z Flip uses ultra-thin glass, but it also incorporates a polymer protective layer. While this layer helps, polymers are softer and less scratch-resistant than glass, leading to some criticism regarding the phone's scratch durability.
High K-Step Glasses for Extreme Applications
These glasses exhibit extremely high fracture resistance due to large "K-steps" (diffusion distance of ions during ion exchange) and very high surface stress. They are used in architectural applications (e.g., bulletproof windows) and military vehicles.
- Chemistry: These are typically aluminum silicate glasses. Alumina boosts the glass transition temperature, allowing for high-temperature treatment to expedite ion diffusion without glass relaxation. They also contain a few percent of magnesium or calcium oxide, which empirically aids alkaline ion diffusion.
- Ion Exchange Process: A mixed ion bath (e.g., sodium and potassium) is used to further increase ion penetration.
- Processing Time: Due to diffusion kinetics, the ion strengthening process for these high K-step glasses can take a very long time, ranging from days to half a month.
- Quantitative Data: Mixed ion baths significantly promote diffusion kinetics, leading to deeper ion penetration. Weibull plots show that mixed ion bath-strengthened glasses achieve much higher strength and improved Weibull modulus (greater consistency).
Chemical Toughening for Glass Containers
Ion exchange (chemical toughening) is widely used for glass containers, especially pharmaceutical vials, where conventional thermal tempering is impractical due to complex geometries and non-uniform thickness.
- COVID-19 Vaccine Vials: The demand for billions of vials during the COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the stringent requirements for these containers.
- Temperature Range: Vials must withstand extreme temperatures (-100°C to +400°C) for storage (e.g., cryogenic vaccines) and sterilization.
- Chemical Resistance: They must resist chemical corrosion from aqueous solutions over long periods, preventing leaching of glass components.
- Surface Damage Resistance: High resistance to wear and tear is crucial for high-throughput manufacturing and packaging.
- Corning Valor Glass: This specialized glass addresses these challenges:
- Boron-Free Formulation: Boron, common in chemically resistant glasses like Pyrex, can cause "delamination" in vials. During the "converting" manufacturing process (cutting and sealing glass tubes at high temperatures), boron can volatilize and redeposit on the surface, creating chemically inhomogeneous patches. These boron-depleted or redeposited areas are more susceptible to chemical attack and can flake off into the solution. Valor Glass's boron-free composition minimizes this issue.
- Proprietary Surface Coating: Prevents wear and tear, increasing manufacturing throughput.
- Ion Exchange: Enhances mechanical strength. The process involves highly automated, parallel treatment of vials in large molten salt baths.
Composite Glass Materials
Combining glass with other materials in composites can further boost properties and reduce damage.
Laminated Glass
This involves alternating layers of glass and polymers.
- Advantages:
- Deformation Absorption: Soft polymer layers absorb deformation and spread stress over a larger glass area.
- Fragment Retention: Even if glass fractures, the polymer holds broken pieces together, preventing dangerous shards.
- Applications: Standard in architectural applications (e.g., Grand Canyon Skywalk) and can be made bulletproof by using multiple layers of glass and polycarbonate. The glass disperses the bullet's force, and the plastic absorbs it.
Flexible and Bendable Glass Devices
Laminated or multi-layer designs can create highly flexible glass devices.
- Neutral Plane Design: In a simple bent sheet, the "neutral plane" in the middle experiences zero stress. Devices sensitive to strain can be placed here. However, this limits device placement (must be embedded) and can be problematic for heat dissipation if the surrounding material is a poor thermal conductor.
- Multi-Neutral Axis Design: An alternative uses two stiff outer layers with a very low Young's modulus material (like rubber) in between. This creates multiple neutral planes, whose positions can be tuned by adjusting layer thicknesses and moduli. This allows devices to be placed closer to the surface, addressing the limitations of the single neutral plane design. This approach enables bending to extremely small radii (e.g., 0.3 mm) and thousands of cycles without damage.
Stretchable Glass Devices
For applications requiring stretchability (e.g., epidermal integration with human skin), the in-plane configuration of the device is altered.
- Photonic Springs: Inspired by helix springs, glass is shaped into meandering, "photonic spring" structures. When stretched, these structures deform both in-plane and out-of-plane, minimizing stress on the glass.
- Stiff Islands: Critical devices that must not deform can be embedded in stiff "islands" interconnected by these meandering structures. The meandering parts absorb all deformation, leaving the stiff islands stress-free. This allows for large elongations and thousands of stretch cycles without damage.
Nacre-Inspired Toughened Glass
Combining out-of-plane lamination with in-plane structuring can create unique mechanical attributes.
- Nacre Microstructure: Nacre (mother-of-pearl) is a tough, flexible material made of calcium carbonate platelets infiltrated with polymer. These platelets can shift relative to each other to absorb deformation.
- Bio-Inspired Design: Researchers engrave trenches into flat glass sheets using laser writing, then laminate them into a multilayer structure. When bent, the glass breaks into individual platelets along the trenches, mimicking nacre's microstructure.
- Optical Transparency: By matching the refractive indices of the glass and polymer, the material remains highly transparent despite its complex microstructure.
- Enhanced Damage Resistance: This nacre-like structure allows platelets to shift, absorbing deformation and preventing crack formation, significantly enhancing damage resistance compared to plain laminated glass.
Key Takeaways on Glass Strengthening
The lecture concludes by summarizing the different strengthening techniques:
- Thermal Tempering:
- Heat-Strengthened Glass: Lower surface stress, no risk of spontaneous breaking.
- Tempered Glass: Higher surface stress, but also large internal tensile stress, which can lead to spontaneous breaking.
- Process: Heated above glass transition temperature, then cooled. Stress accumulates during cooling as temperature gradients convert to thermal stress.
- Chemically Strengthened Glass:
- Process: Ion exchange takes place below the glass transition temperature to prevent relaxation of the induced compressive stress.
- Spontaneous Breaking: Does not break spontaneously due to the smaller surface thickness of the chemical stress layer.
Problem Set Discussion
The lecture briefly reviews a problem set, emphasizing:
- Bulk Metallic Glasses (BMGs): Vitreloy can be cast up to 2.2 cm thick without crystallization due to its high resistance to crystallization. Thermoplastic forming methods like compression molding are compatible, offering a processing window of over three minutes. Injection molding is also viable but less preferred due to higher temperatures and a narrower time window.
- Glass Relaxation: When glass relaxes, its volume (and enthalpy) should always decrease towards the supercooled liquid state, not increase.
- Heat Released During Heat Treatment: The heat flux (dH/dt) during heating and cooling cycles can be analyzed by considering the slope of the enthalpy-temperature curve (dH/dT) and the heating/cooling rate (dT/dt). The curve shows distinct phases of heat release (cooling, relaxation) and absorption (reheating).
- Cryonics and Amorphization: The concept of cryonics (cryogenic hibernation) relies on preventing ice crystal formation in body fluids by vitrifying them into a glassy state at cryogenic temperatures. Amorphous materials are crucial for this to avoid cellular damage upon freezing and thawing.
Metallic Glass Demo
A demonstration highlights the unique mechanical properties of metallic glasses. A stainless steel ball bounces significantly higher off a metallic glass surface compared to an aluminum surface. This is because aluminum undergoes plastic deformation, absorbing energy, while metallic glass, lacking dislocations, has a much higher elastic limit and yield strength. It stores impact energy as elastic energy, leading to minimal damping and a higher bounce.
Takeaways
- Ion exchange creates a surface compressive stress layer that shifts the Weibull plot rightward, giving chemically strengthened glass higher strength and a steeper slope that indicates a higher Weibull modulus and more consistent defect distribution.
- New glass technologies—including scratch‑resistant coatings, native damage‑resistant glass that uses boron coordination changes, and ultra‑thin chemically strengthened glass—enable screens that resist scratches and can bend without cracking.
- High K‑step glasses and chemically toughened containers employ mixed‑ion baths and ion exchange to achieve extreme surface compressive stresses, delivering superior strength and consistency for applications like bullet‑proof windows and COVID‑19 vaccine vials.
- Composite designs such as laminated glass, multi‑neutral‑axis structures, and nacre‑inspired micro‑layered glass absorb deformation across layers or platelets, allowing flexible, stretchable, and highly damage‑resistant devices.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does sapphire's higher Young's modulus increase the risk of screen failure on low-modulus casings?
Sapphire's Young's modulus is about five times that of typical glass, so when it is bonded to a low‑modulus casing the screen becomes the stiffest component and absorbs most of an impact's stress. This concentration of stress raises the likelihood of crack initiation in the sapphire, whereas a high‑modulus casing (e.g., stainless steel) shares the load and reduces failure risk.
What is the mechanism behind native damage‑resistant (NDR) glass's improved scratch resistance?
Native damage‑resistant (NDR) glass improves scratch resistance by using boron atoms that switch coordination under stress, increasing network connectivity and density. When a scratch applies pressure, three‑fold coordinated B³ transforms to four‑fold B⁴, causing localized densification that absorbs deformation and prevents microcrack formation.
Who is MIT OpenCourseWare on YouTube?
MIT OpenCourseWare is a YouTube channel that publishes videos on a range of topics. Browse more summaries from this channel below.
Does this page include the full transcript of the video?
Yes, the full transcript for this video is available on this page. Click 'Show transcript' in the sidebar to read it.
Helpful resources related to this video
If you want to practice or explore the concepts discussed in the video, these commonly used tools may help.
Links may be affiliate links. We only include resources that are genuinely relevant to the topic.